Message from @Puppet Master

Discord ID: 644695854426619939


2019-11-15 00:24:28 UTC  

i suspect black a moors were the converts they brought with them

2019-11-15 00:24:40 UTC  

That's quite possible tbh

2019-11-15 00:25:00 UTC  

i know in later years they started depicting moors as black

2019-11-15 00:25:16 UTC  

The paintings however do well to show their beards and turbans, so we're at the very least talking about a population from NA/the Levant

2019-11-15 00:25:38 UTC  

It could be at the time that Levantine DNA/rulership was more prominent from that region

2019-11-15 00:25:46 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/619334636241289231/644694499884400670/ccf8bbe7a0db608e3dd7fe396765a97a.jpg

2019-11-15 00:25:47 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/619334636241289231/644694503202095104/idris_10.jpg

2019-11-15 00:25:57 UTC  

these are berbers, from same area as moors

2019-11-15 00:26:39 UTC  

Yeah, I'm discussing it at home right now

2019-11-15 00:26:42 UTC  

I'm not buying it

2019-11-15 00:26:57 UTC  

For one, it's quite possible that the illustrators didn't have any contact with the Moors

2019-11-15 00:27:01 UTC  

the turks were also originally a red haired people and muhammed had red hair

2019-11-15 00:27:06 UTC  

And are detailing accounts of the story.

2019-11-15 00:27:27 UTC  

well the paintings of black moors were all done over 100 years after the invasion

2019-11-15 00:28:29 UTC  

It could be that Europeans eventually became more learned about North Africans by that time

2019-11-15 00:29:01 UTC  

Also, we'd need to see whether or not the Berbers/the like actually represented a significant genetic majority in the region around the time

2019-11-15 00:29:10 UTC  

the native north african population is the berbers not blacks btw

2019-11-15 00:29:34 UTC  

blacks moved in later

2019-11-15 00:30:14 UTC  

Eh, ish. There's been so much population movement in those regions over thousands of years.

2019-11-15 00:31:01 UTC  

Let me see if I can find a Principle Component Analysis with historical North African samples

2019-11-15 00:31:09 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/619334636241289231/644695854426619935/1457490_654831737872713_2031159040_n.jpg

2019-11-15 00:31:10 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/619334636241289231/644695857014243338/ancient-egypt23.jpg

2019-11-15 00:32:09 UTC  

there are caucasian mummies found in west china, why is north africa hard to believe?

2019-11-15 00:32:09 UTC  

🆙 | **Puppet Master leveled up!**

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/619334636241289231/644696105317171200/levelUp.png

2019-11-15 00:32:50 UTC  

Yes, I'm firmly aware, but we need to ascertain whether or not the Moors were significantly more Africanized by the time they made contact in Iberia.

2019-11-15 00:33:24 UTC  

I mean, for one, if the Moors were White, why is it we see even a minimal degree of African admixture at the Horn?

2019-11-15 00:33:59 UTC  

This admixture is likely to stem from the presence of the Moors in the area before they were expelled

2019-11-15 00:35:04 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/619334636241289231/644696839601258499/African-admixture.png

2019-11-15 00:36:02 UTC  

most historical depictions i find of the moors show pale skinned people. only more modern pictures show them as black

2019-11-15 00:36:45 UTC  

blacks may have been brought up through that area because of the arab slave trade

2019-11-15 00:37:08 UTC  

not that there were not any there before, just not as large a population

2019-11-15 00:39:21 UTC  

Also, those opinions were of England's Elizabeth, my bad. Not Isabella. Just to offer a correction.

2019-11-15 00:39:42 UTC  

plenty of mixin goin on

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/619334636241289231/644698005252866059/images.jpg

2019-11-15 00:39:55 UTC  

np

2019-11-15 00:40:57 UTC  

the problem is that europeans basically called anyone who was black or arab a moor at one point

2019-11-15 00:41:50 UTC  

Boi 😩

2019-11-15 00:42:29 UTC  

Presence of Haplogroup H in general isn't going to help us determine *what time it got there*

2019-11-15 00:42:37 UTC  

For one.

2019-11-15 00:43:23 UTC  

Two, the most "White-looking" and prevalent one in antiquity would be E1b1/variants of E

2019-11-15 00:44:03 UTC  

That's if we're assuming that the people settled in this region still looked anything like those from the Levant.