Message from @lancelout

Discord ID: 604117133651214339


2019-07-26 01:01:29 UTC  

here ill show original source

2019-07-26 01:01:32 UTC  

as its unclear

2019-07-26 01:02:50 UTC  

damn original book in behind pay wall of some sort

2019-07-26 01:02:59 UTC  

"prior to world war 2"

2019-07-26 01:03:31 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/598762957257703438/604116555336253460/table2.jpg

2019-07-26 01:03:38 UTC  

those numbers you posted

2019-07-26 01:03:43 UTC  

were garbage

2019-07-26 01:03:46 UTC  

mentioned in link I provided

2019-07-26 01:04:01 UTC  

soviet government provided garbage numbers for estimates

2019-07-26 01:04:13 UTC  

the numbers i posted aren't the official estimates

2019-07-26 01:04:31 UTC  

here are the facts june

2019-07-26 01:04:36 UTC  

they were derived from national accounting done by german economists in the 2000's iirc

2019-07-26 01:04:55 UTC  

Here are the facts june

2019-07-26 01:05:08 UTC  

east germany went from being ahead of west germany immediately after the war

2019-07-26 01:05:13 UTC  

to 30 percent of it and backwards

2019-07-26 01:05:20 UTC  

it wasn't ahead *after* the war

2019-07-26 01:05:26 UTC  

the stats you are showing are showing it was ahead before the war

2019-07-26 01:05:29 UTC  

I already provided source on that

2019-07-26 01:05:42 UTC  

you provided a source that shows it was ahead before the war not after

2019-07-26 01:05:48 UTC  

The stats I provided were soviet stats

2019-07-26 01:05:57 UTC  

jesus man this is getting sad

2019-07-26 01:06:00 UTC  

here ill post it again

2019-07-26 01:06:56 UTC  

In 1946, the Soviet zone had a slight total factor productivity lead

2019-07-26 01:07:03 UTC  

wartime industrialization had contributed more to the eastern economy, and the destruction caused by the war was lighter than in the west.[4] However, by 1948 the western zones had become more prosperous.[4]

2019-07-26 01:07:10 UTC  

Ritschl, A.; Vonyo, T. (17 April 2014). "The roots of economic failure: what explains East Germany's falling behind between 1945 and 1950?". European Review of Economic History. 18 (2): 166–184. doi:10.1093/ereh/heu004.

2019-07-26 01:07:42 UTC  

I mean

2019-07-26 01:07:46 UTC  

Abstract
The relative decline of the East German economy after 1945 has eluded researchers, as several large shocks appeared to have hit it at the same time. In this paper, we revisit the immediate post-war period in both parts of Germany to obtain a more comprehensive picture of the output and productivity shocks operating in both economies. Our principal finding is that the dismantling of the capital stock alone cannot explain the inferior performance of the East German economy. The collapse of output after the war and the ensuing recovery in both parts of the country were driven by total factor productivity; changes in factor endowments were of second-order significance. West Germany began to lead East Germany in industrial labor productivity well before the economic reforms of 1948 could make their mark. The major factor contributing to this early divergence were disproportions in industrial structure caused by the division of Germany.

2019-07-26 01:07:52 UTC  

As someone who comes from Eastern Europe

2019-07-26 01:08:02 UTC  

East germany started out with a lead

2019-07-26 01:08:21 UTC  

the idea that commie economy was just as good as Westernfag economy is just laughable tbh

2019-07-26 01:08:21 UTC  

and ended up a fraction of west germanys economy

2019-07-26 01:08:38 UTC  

and east germany was the most productive part of the soviet bloc

2019-07-26 01:08:49 UTC  

total factor productivity isn't gdp

2019-07-26 01:08:53 UTC  

It goes against literally all that I have seen through my life

2019-07-26 01:09:04 UTC  

it's reality denial

2019-07-26 01:09:11 UTC  

might as well call the earth flat

2019-07-26 01:09:24 UTC  

i mean i never said it was just as good

2019-07-26 01:09:34 UTC  

and the west doesn't represent most of capitalism either

2019-07-26 01:09:53 UTC  

well it kind of does actually