Message from @Αγωνιζῆς

Discord ID: 607344041629057055


2019-08-03 22:45:13 UTC  

i'm not even kidding

2019-08-03 22:45:23 UTC  

You say it like it's impossible to analyse culture @Αγωνιζῆς

2019-08-03 22:45:44 UTC  

What my point is that such generalizations should only be made with sufficient evidence

2019-08-03 22:45:48 UTC  

I say declaring that all germans have the same worldview is nonsense

2019-08-03 22:46:02 UTC  

Insofar, it is difficult to analyse culture in this regard

2019-08-03 22:46:05 UTC  

I don think he's saying that

2019-08-03 22:46:08 UTC  

^^

2019-08-03 22:46:30 UTC  

'the German', 'the English' , seems pretty definitive to me

2019-08-03 22:46:49 UTC  

The english mindset and the german mindset

2019-08-03 22:46:49 UTC  

I thick he's saying there are cultural narratives common in one culture, and other ones in another. And the ones in German culture are being applied to English culture, which is nonsense

2019-08-03 22:46:55 UTC  

Suddenly it makes more sense when you finish the word

2019-08-03 22:47:20 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/598762957257703438/607343770274365453/20190804_004631_HDR.jpg

2019-08-03 22:47:26 UTC  

built this ne myself

2019-08-03 22:47:27 UTC  

but this connects a worldview with a certain nationality whitch is arbitrary

2019-08-03 22:47:32 UTC  

No

2019-08-03 22:47:42 UTC  

All it says is that this is where these worldviews come from

2019-08-03 22:47:42 UTC  

Do u not nuance? Do ppl have to put a #Not_All in front of everything for you to grasp that they are making a generalization, not a universal statement about a category of object?

2019-08-03 22:47:49 UTC  
2019-08-03 22:48:04 UTC  

why not? It implies there is something inherenly 'English' about the ideas of locke

2019-08-03 22:48:12 UTC  

The german mindset #notall #culturesnotraces #diverse

2019-08-03 22:48:23 UTC  

and inherently 'German' about the Kantian philosophy

2019-08-03 22:48:31 UTC  

Well yes the ideas of locke were first adapted and spread from England

2019-08-03 22:48:35 UTC  

so?

2019-08-03 22:48:37 UTC  

i only know the bavarian mindset, which is very territorial (and rightfully so)

2019-08-03 22:48:41 UTC  

I think what Sargon argued that the German culture, on average, is more susceptible to authoritarian ideologies than the 'English culture'

2019-08-03 22:48:54 UTC  

So stop nitpicking on fucking words lmao

2019-08-03 22:48:55 UTC  

But this thing @Αγωνιζῆς is saying is EXACLY what I criticized the video 4 in the 1st place in the post that started this discussion...

2019-08-03 22:49:00 UTC  

Which also requires strong evidence

2019-08-03 22:49:09 UTC  

He's being unclear and fags will take it that way

2019-08-03 22:49:51 UTC  

@Monstrous Moonshine evidence that I feel like he's provided

2019-08-03 22:49:55 UTC  

He's being generally rather uncouth about his way of presenting this point

2019-08-03 22:50:01 UTC  

which does not invalidate the point

2019-08-03 22:50:15 UTC  

Like I wrote in my original wall of text it connects a lot of dots about contemporary politics and behaviours

2019-08-03 22:50:26 UTC  

just means he hasn't discussed it with many lefties to learn how to make it stronger against their efforts of delegitimizing it

2019-08-03 22:51:08 UTC  

If their efforts of delegitimizing it are bitching about not saying #notall that feels like they can't debunk it to me

2019-08-03 22:51:25 UTC  

We'll see if there's any large scale response soon

2019-08-03 22:51:28 UTC  

For instance he's taking the British national narrative as true in the historical sense (which it is manifestly not) instead of saying that it informs British thinking and self-image enough to be a social reality regardless of being a historical reality

2019-08-03 22:51:33 UTC  

English culture was very authoritarian in empire days

2019-08-03 22:52:03 UTC  

But as Sargon also stated it was these ideas that helped move Britain away from authoritarianism

2019-08-03 22:52:28 UTC  

We must find new lands from which we can easily obtain raw materials and at the same time exploit the cheap slave labor that is available from the natives of the colonies. The colonies would also provide a dumping ground for the surplus goods produced in our factories. Cecil Rhodes

2019-08-03 22:52:48 UTC  

Yes and?