Message from @Jym

Discord ID: 621148185141706772


2019-09-11 00:53:09 UTC  

WWII is a good example

2019-09-11 00:53:22 UTC  

It took us forever to finally be directly involved

2019-09-11 00:53:25 UTC  

it's usually very slow

2019-09-11 00:53:39 UTC  

Relations between the U.S. and Turkey have been shaky since the iraq war though

2019-09-11 00:53:48 UTC  

if its done properly, sure

2019-09-11 00:53:51 UTC  

"Relations between the countries began to deteriorate in 2003 as Turkey refused to allow the United States to use Incirlik Air Base for the invasion of Iraq, a process that intensified following the failed coup d'état attempt in Turkey in July 2016 as the country′s foreign policy has gradually re-orientated towards seeking partnerships with other powers such as Russia"

2019-09-11 00:54:13 UTC  

but then bush and obama decided to infantalize the role of congress on the matter

2019-09-11 00:55:39 UTC  

then next thing you know, we've got, whats the count now, 8 "military commitments?" [because shhh its not war, because reasons]

2019-09-11 00:56:11 UTC  

Well technically low intensity conflicts against terrorism are not actually war

2019-09-11 00:56:25 UTC  

But the iraq war is a war since it's against another nation. Fighting non-state entity is often times deemed to be something else

2019-09-11 00:56:36 UTC  

>"terrorism"
we just had this discussion

2019-09-11 00:56:39 UTC  

Functionally though it's irrelevant since the use of force laws are more or less the same

2019-09-11 00:56:56 UTC  

We haven't really invaded a major country in a while

2019-09-11 00:57:08 UTC  

Just been involved in the same territory, like we fight against ISIS in Syria

2019-09-11 00:57:13 UTC  

But not actually fought Syria

2019-09-11 00:58:17 UTC  

And yet we fought Al-qaeda in Iraq until they're effectively gone, but we're still there, and just keep finding reasons to stay.

2019-09-11 00:58:24 UTC  

identifying a pattern yet?

2019-09-11 00:58:47 UTC  

invasion without official declaration of war

2019-09-11 00:58:55 UTC  

Caesar would be impressed

2019-09-11 01:00:44 UTC  

politically its ingenius

2019-09-11 01:01:07 UTC  

Iraq is a mess. Swartzkopf was right when he said we have no national interest in toppling Iraq. Regardless of intention the removal of that power has created a vaccum so when we leave Iran will complete their drive to move in.

2019-09-11 01:01:24 UTC  

though only a state as phenonenally unequalled in power would be able to get away with it

2019-09-11 01:01:52 UTC  

>Iran
not even going to dignify that

2019-09-11 01:02:05 UTC  

Well staying behind is important in preventing another catastrophe from happening. When you pull out, it leaves behind a power vacuume, and it's common for someone to come in and fill it. When we left Vietnam, millions of people were killed, raped and tortured, because as one might expect, us deciding to leave did not mean the Viet Cong were going to leave their own country and stop fighting. The moment we leave, they will regroup and come back, as evidenced by the partial withdrawal in Iraq leading to an uprising in the terrorists again, and virtually every other time pulling out has failed. The cost of maintaining a small troop presence to keep a lid on things is quite small, so it's worth doing so another massive troop surge is not needed.

2019-09-11 01:02:37 UTC  

Also iraq has for the most part improved

2019-09-11 01:03:12 UTC  

"The country's electricity had dropped from a 9300 megawatt capacity in 1990 to 3300 by early 2003 before the U.S. invasion, nearly a third, and rose to a 13,000 megawatt capacity as of 2016, after the U.S. intervention. [3][4] Saddam selectively cut off power to groups he was attempting to murder, such as the Kurds, and left them without food, water and electricity in a barren desert that was almost impossible to survive in without. Access to clean water had been reduced dramatically, and in 2004 only approximately 45% of rural areas had access to clean water and 96% in urban areas, compared to 77% in rural areas and 98% in urban areas in 2012, with a dramatic improvement in the quality of the water as well, particularly in regards to salt content, as well."

2019-09-11 01:03:28 UTC  

GDP has gone up from basically zero to 230 billion dollars ayear

2019-09-11 01:03:39 UTC  

Iran is a regional power. Nature abhors a vacum. I suppose it is also possible that Turkey or SA will move in but basically *someone* is going to dominate that area and it won't be the Iraqis.

2019-09-11 01:03:54 UTC  

Saddam released all the prisoners, turned off the power and so on, and the country was a mess before we invaded

2019-09-11 01:04:03 UTC  

While it's not a Utopia by any standards, it's far better than it was

2019-09-11 01:04:21 UTC  

The saddam regime was destabilizing, in part by his actions, and so U.S. intervention made sense as a way to keep the country from going off a cliff

2019-09-11 01:04:36 UTC  

It's actually not doing worse

2019-09-11 01:04:44 UTC  

Like objectivley everything is improving

2019-09-11 01:04:48 UTC  

By every metric

2019-09-11 01:05:01 UTC  

Previous to our bumble-headed intervention there was a ballance of power between Iran and Iraq. That is now gone.

2019-09-11 01:05:07 UTC  

Thats nice, can we leave now?

2019-09-11 01:05:30 UTC  

we have our own problems

2019-09-11 01:05:36 UTC  

Probably yeah we can leave it won't hurt *us*.

2019-09-11 01:06:17 UTC  

Leaving would undue all the good we've built up and allow the country to fall again

2019-09-11 01:06:34 UTC  

why is it even our fucking problem