Message from @ETBrooD

Discord ID: 641134789377654803


2019-11-05 04:38:10 UTC  

No, I see the possibility only

2019-11-05 04:38:15 UTC  

That's agnostic atheist.

2019-11-05 04:38:17 UTC  

Yes

2019-11-05 04:38:32 UTC  

Ok. You admitted it. Agnostic **atheist**.

2019-11-05 04:38:41 UTC  

Glad we got to the conclusion.

2019-11-05 04:38:46 UTC  

Yes, because that's how the terminology evolved over time, but I'm not an *atheist*

2019-11-05 04:39:21 UTC  

Nope, I have it screencapped:

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/633967335614447636/641134431041749012/unknown.png

2019-11-05 04:39:24 UTC  

You seem to believe that just because people have added the term "atheist" to "agnostic", that somehow makes it different

2019-11-05 04:39:35 UTC  

Agnostic = agnostic atheist

2019-11-05 04:39:36 UTC  

But

2019-11-05 04:39:39 UTC  

Atheist =/= agnostic

2019-11-05 04:39:53 UTC  

The most proper terminology would be agnostic

2019-11-05 04:40:04 UTC  

Agnostic atheist is just a fancy term for saying "I'm kinda uncertain what I am"

2019-11-05 04:40:07 UTC  

Agnostic != agnostic atheist, because agnostic can also be agnostic theist.

2019-11-05 04:40:12 UTC  

non-binary genderbender

2019-11-05 04:40:16 UTC  

Wrong, Agnostic = agnostic atheist

2019-11-05 04:40:22 UTC  

Agnostic atheist is only a subgroup of agnostics.

2019-11-05 04:40:26 UTC  

No it's not

2019-11-05 04:40:36 UTC  

Explain what the difference is between agnosticism and agnostic atheism

2019-11-05 04:40:39 UTC  

You are an atheist:

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/633967335614447636/641134758478348298/unknown.png

2019-11-05 04:40:45 UTC  

Explain what the difference is between agnosticism and agnostic atheism

2019-11-05 04:42:18 UTC  

Gnostic theist: I know god exists and I can prove it!
Agnostic theist: I believe god exists but I cannot prove it...
Agnostic atheist: I don't believe god exist but I have no proof...
Gnostic atheist: God does not exist because science, POOF!

2019-11-05 04:42:42 UTC  

I asked you

2019-11-05 04:42:46 UTC  

Explain what the difference is between agnosticism and agnostic atheism

2019-11-05 04:42:50 UTC  

Where is agnosticism on that list?

2019-11-05 04:42:56 UTC  

this is how you get people believing in 52 genders

2019-11-05 04:42:58 UTC  

There's no such thing as "agnosticism" with being attached to theism or atheism.

2019-11-05 04:43:08 UTC  

Agnosticism is its own idea

2019-11-05 04:43:10 UTC  

What is the idea?

2019-11-05 04:43:16 UTC  

That's like asking what's the difference between libertarian and rightwing libertarian.

2019-11-05 04:43:25 UTC  

I want you to explain to me what the idea of agnosticism is

2019-11-05 04:43:27 UTC  

Which is nonsensical question.

2019-11-05 04:43:31 UTC  

No it's not

2019-11-05 04:43:35 UTC  

Agnosticism has a definition

2019-11-05 04:43:46 UTC  

So does libertarianism.

2019-11-05 04:43:51 UTC  

Then tell me what it is

2019-11-05 04:44:01 UTC  

But asking what's difference between right-wing libertarian and libertarian in general, is nonsense.

2019-11-05 04:44:05 UTC  

Explain the difference

2019-11-05 04:44:19 UTC  

I'm not letting you get away with this, tell us

2019-11-05 04:44:32 UTC  

the separation in my head between an atheistic-agnostic and agnostic-atheism is that the latter goes ahead and asserts a claim (albite a weak one)

2019-11-05 04:44:32 UTC  

speak for yourself fedorablender