Message from @Killzone
Discord ID: 634078723875799054
I mean, pre modern freedom is always pretty limited, but ability to choose life paths is the most notable difference. Most of the nobility was recruited for most dynasties. Furthermore physical mobility was far more tolerated, as in walking/riding to a different area, which was illegal for many in feudal Europe/Russia.
Which was illegal because you were going into a different country, sure.
Movement was fine because of the massive scale of China
No I mean In the same country
the way china governs now is very similar to how they governed under the philosophy of legalism back in 400-200~ bc
England was better than most, but most people legally were barred from leaving their home towns except if they were drafted/given specific permission from their local lord. It was like this from the late Roman period to the middle enlightenment
Anyway, it's been a VERY long time since the Chinese have had privileges like they do now
So they don't really care
Not really, you could make a case for the quin dynasty being better for them, or even the civil war
was this true when china was feudal
I guess really... it comes down to whether or not you think sacrificing things for a national identity or national purpose is a good thing or not....
china moved past feudalism long before the west did
The entire CCPs plan is to renew the 'Chinese identity'
If by renew you mean destroy and replace
Then sure
Yep
right and thats what im getting at... is that the gov in china thinks that the chinese people sacrificing certain things for the national identity/national purpose of china is a good thing for their people as a whole
for their future generations. and also they like power
and many of the chinese also agree with this
Liberalism... liberal democracies... they sort of invert that idea. Positing that personal sovereignty/freedom is far more important then any proposed national purpose/identity
The chinese would laugh at the later... and say "you mean becoming a multi-cultural society like yours? Because thats turning out so great isnt it? You guys cant even leave the EU <:pot_of_kek:544849795433496586> "
And their culture is different
But so what?
what about Taiwan. how's that situation going to pan out
Hard to say
I'm not a cultural relativist, the modern Chinese culture sucks
China will likely bring them into their sphere
Through covert actions
Then again, I'm not sure
Taiwan is something like 95% stay independent
With like 4% saying they should retake china.
Their opinion of china ranges from negative to mixed
hmm idk... once the spirit of personal freedom is ignited in a society... its very very difficult to turn it around
Easily done through indoctrination from birth
right but you have to get to that point though... to begin with
and parents arent going to do that if they themselves also believe in personal freedom
Those that support the CCP can be given help from the mainland
So even if the taiwanese government was subverted by china
So they rise in the political system
the people would resist