Message from @Cyborg

Discord ID: 598782692422582272


2019-07-11 07:43:23 UTC  

Mao abolished that so its irrelevant to my standing

2019-07-11 07:43:51 UTC  

>mao

2019-07-11 07:43:54 UTC  

we aren't on PRC

2019-07-11 07:44:37 UTC  

The USSR still had a system which did not show a full value of labor. It was still based on capital production and was still beyond the actual production times.

2019-07-11 07:44:47 UTC  

aka, wages still existed

2019-07-11 07:45:10 UTC  

So what was it then

2019-07-11 07:45:38 UTC  

Ive heard you retards call it "state industrialism", which is moronic

2019-07-11 07:45:48 UTC  

>ignoring what I just said

2019-07-11 07:45:55 UTC  

You just reverted the topic

2019-07-11 07:46:40 UTC  

Apparently finbol has a better understanding of Marx than you, doubt you would even hold up debating him

2019-07-11 07:46:47 UTC  

<a:stoner:586330335084806144>

2019-07-11 07:47:00 UTC  

Just ignores the fact they literally had wage labor

2019-07-11 07:47:12 UTC  

Are you EVER gonna respond to what I said

2019-07-11 07:47:17 UTC  

or just bullshit your way out

2019-07-11 07:47:18 UTC  

>wage labour bad and not socialist

2019-07-11 07:47:27 UTC  

Wage labor is literally NOT Socialism

2019-07-11 07:47:35 UTC  

that is a fucking core tenet of what it *doesn't* have

2019-07-11 07:47:52 UTC  

>literally every socialist state has retained wage labour

2019-07-11 07:48:21 UTC  

>when they didn't abandon the capital mode of production
>when they all maintained capital

2019-07-11 07:48:30 UTC  

*capital* mode of production btw

2019-07-11 07:48:38 UTC  

Not Capital*ist*

2019-07-11 07:49:44 UTC  

You can't just keep using the "muh commodity form and red fascism" to distance your ideology from things you find hard to defend, like gulags and famines, you literally only hold these dumb beliefs just so you can bullshit your way out of anti socialist arguments

2019-07-11 07:49:59 UTC  

Bruh, you are just ignoring it now

2019-07-11 07:50:10 UTC  

>ignoring it

2019-07-11 07:50:16 UTC  

no, im insulting you

2019-07-11 07:50:29 UTC  

I literally never distanced from it. I still defend alot of Soviet aspects.

*But they weren't Socialists in the initial nature, which is what I am after*

2019-07-11 07:50:34 UTC  

Yes, because you can't argue

2019-07-11 07:50:43 UTC  

Of course the anarchist tard can only reduce to insults

2019-07-11 07:50:48 UTC  

Then debate finbol

2019-07-11 07:51:23 UTC  

Oh, you cant because you are literally to much of a coward to go on his server in VC and do so

2019-07-11 07:51:48 UTC  

```Since under capitalism wages are the price of labour-power```
https://www.marxists.org/subject/economy/authors/pe/pe-ch33.htm

They did their payments based upon the exchange values (see piece-rate system). Unironically the only difference is it's a fixed wage

2019-07-11 07:52:03 UTC  

```Oh, you cant because you are literally to much of a coward to go on his server in VC and do so```
So I can have 15 people yell at me for disagreeing?

2019-07-11 07:52:05 UTC  

What's the matter

2019-07-11 07:52:09 UTC  

can't argue for yourself?

2019-07-11 07:52:25 UTC  

>implying everyone is a debater

2019-07-11 07:52:59 UTC  

no, but you are obviously not going to debate someone who can debate you, because you'd be afraid of losing

2019-07-11 07:53:24 UTC  

yes Leah, because you don't have to be a debater to understand concepts.

Such as wage labor, or commodity-production

Finbol can hit me up anytime and if he presents something solid, he can have it. I don't care to be right. I care if I am not disproven and you're still claiming shit.

2019-07-11 07:53:36 UTC  

I debate people who CAN debate me every single day

2019-07-11 07:53:39 UTC  

Finbol is not some god

2019-07-11 07:54:28 UTC  

If you want, tell him I disagree. I'm not gonna go and vc and debate, sure. Purely because it's much easier to trip up, miss something.

I like my conversations to be *conclusive* and have everything needed to be said, said.

2019-07-11 07:54:39 UTC  

Then literally go in ULP and do so