but is memory biological?

I don't know what you mean by that. I'm stupid, I apologize.

The RNA didn’t self assemble, the components of rna assembled

Even then they'd still die from even the slightest of hosilte conditions. And earth back then was anything but the garden of eden

It's psychological

The fact is they think that the conditions might have maybe been like early earths. Then on top of that they also did this in a lab. In a real setting things are MUCH different

I would say it’s biological but am not totally sure

Water used, don't come back for a day, it was super effective, RNA has died

Lol

Also in order for the RNA to evolve into anything capable of surviving. Even a nucleus. It would have to remain in stable conditions for so long.

Well I've been studying psychology and psychology means "study of the soul" and in that region is memory

RNA would first have to become dna

DNA is incredibly fragile though.

All this stuff is fragile so fragile it couldn’t evolve

Man could walk around with a swagger stick

animals have memory(not quite the way humans do though) but I wouldn't say that they have consciousness, animals act on instinct.

Biology says form determines function

but isn't rna useless without dna?

Then isn't that a case against evolution?

Yes it is

I believe god spat on the earth rubbed it with his pinkie finger and we skipped all the algae turning into whale bullcrap.

I'm a heretic I apologize

Yes

I tend to think of God as a sculptor and maestro.

Then it had to have been a flawed study.

The study wasn’t flawed it just wasn’t as useful as they toured it to be

ah

Calling it life’s first spark also seems like it could be an exaggeration to me

so they conflated the importance of their findings

what I'm wondering is, was there even any genetic information in the rna?

Yes but they didn’t create actual rna

They created one component out of several of rna

ok, yeah I think I remember you saying that earlier

got it

Yep, just wanted to make sure we were clear LOL

just because they have one of or even all of the components doesn't mean that they will inevitably form into rna.

Exactly

You will have to wait millions of years 😂

Most people dont realize that mutations tend to cause deficiencies, illnesses, and sometimes death. And no hereditary changes have caused newfound abilities and mechanisms, much less speciation

That's why evolution (macro) is so flawed