Message from @BigJim
Discord ID: 804258873447284766
Well in that case their is a lack of pleasure and likely some pain involved meaning that I would not want that to happen.
it is not a coherent concept
When you don't simplify it to much I think it is perfectly coherent.
Some of it seems a little paradoxical at first but I personally think that for the most part it is pretty coherent.
you started this by saying pain should be abolished
To the most optimal extent possible. Maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain must be done at the optimal balanced level.
It is possible I was being a little sloppy with my language earlier but I do think that pain should be abolished to the greatest extent possible to the point that it starts to damage peoples capacity to feel proper pleasure.
the optimal level of pain is right at your limit
there's a technical term for it that escapes me right now
the limit being the treshold between manageable and unmanageable
Excess of pleasure can be harmful
Equally like lack of pain
If an excess of pleasure causes a large amount of pain then I oppose it as it is creating pain.
If a small amount of pain maximizes pleasure in the long term then I may support it.
<:thinkingsuicide:793674864619683840>
You no like?
What basic level goal informs your political views then?
hes a utilitarian
the expansion of my collective's material conditions
you
you literally defined utilitarianism here lol
and that is not the basis of liberalism
Cool
yeah you could use utilitarianism to justify brutal tyranny if you wanted
Depending on your views on how tyranny impacts the common good of people.
I would argue it is destructive to peoples well being.
ingolfr what is your basic level goal that informs your political views?
at the most basic level it is the same as what aqua said
protection of the ingroup versus the outgroup/s
Yes because you are all tribalists
expansion of the ingroup
I care for both in groups and out groups.
no you don't
Why care for just one when you can care for both?
Oh yes I do
well for one because different groups have different material interests
I might be able to vc with you in an hour
I might be able to voice chat then