genius economics

stalin cut the grain exports when crisis developed

/\

that's true

but

explain your point what you mean by "export rather than eat"

USSR was net exporter of grain because it was simply producing more it could consume for most of the time

what should they do? sponsor state obesity? or get funds for chad industrialisation?

state obesity !!!!

It exported grain to import industrial equipment because there were balance of payment issues

truly a problem in 1930

s

This should be simple to understand

and what's wrong with it

explain your point

they could have stored some food maybe

most of industrialisations in the world are fueled by exports revenues

for the dark days

brazil, mexico, iran, turkey

just read history

they could've just not stole all the wheat and artificially forced a mass famine

It exported more to accelerate the import and development of industry, so yes it led to less consumption

wrong

but clearly I am in the wrong here

It was not the same pace

you have no data to back it up

they didnt

as I said USSR had better food security than tsarist russia

ahaha

Not really true

economy tsarist russia is practically anarchy from what i understood

they had private farms

that fed people

that's obviously true, simply USSR eliminated cyclical famines

Both were autarkic but the civil war wrecked productivity

in tsarist russia you had famine every decade or two

tbf the only country that didn't have cyclical famines for a long time was britain

And later collectivization didn't help

USSR had so called holomodor and then ww2

later there was no hunger

that's a fact