Message from @TwinVickers
Discord ID: 563227357695967242
A straw man is an oversimplification or a caricature of someone's position that you refute instead of the actual point, in order to then pretend you did just that.
i feel that when you need to use meta to try and win an argument you've already lost
but i'm an autistic boomer i hear
Then you cannot argue logically.
obv
Logic will necessarily have to generalize.
which is my failsafe
How do you know that every pug is a dog but not every dog is a pug?
i read
I am sorry, but reading is too meta.
kinda makes convos hard on discord
i think what you wanted to ask was for me to explain why pugs are always dogs but not all dogs are pugs
If you are unable to generalize, which logical reasoning basically is, then you can't really intelligently live in this world.
what is living intelligently?
Well, being able to reason about your environment.
Skills such as planning, learning or generalization.
Basically what lifeforms above plants are doing.
Did you have an aneurysm?
RIP
😦
Ah, okay.
BRB
coffee
well i don't know if i've lived intelligently. arguments could be made either way but i'm not dead so that might say i have lived intelligently. i'm not saying i'm a greybeard but at this point i probably would have deaded otherwise
But you miraculously evaded the definition of a straw man in debate. Remarkable.
i've only seen it used as a meta
Meta as opposed to what?
as in "that is clearly a straw man so your argument is invalid" instead of "i see, well because your assumption is based on a = 1 and a is clearly 2... you can't be right"
If I say "No, that wasn't really my point and you knew that." I'm not sure if it makes much sense to argue about a = 1 or b = banana.
so we come to the conclusion that we have different ideas on what a straw man is, i assumed it meant that the argument could be deconstructed by removing a proverbial straw from it
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
<:pepe_eyes:378719408362881024>
I guess we just had different ideas about it.
imagine memorising that
People can memorize baseball stats spanning decades.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
My kids can memorize dozens of Pokemen.
(and pokewomen)
i don't think memorizing that is an option either
