Message from @ELIS314

Discord ID: 794979046596411403


2021-01-02 17:16:36 UTC  

But if you want a contextual understand of a period and people definitely look at the art and culture of the time

2021-01-02 17:17:41 UTC  

History should be presented objectively and from the context of that era, not ideologically.

2021-01-02 17:18:17 UTC  

Agreed. And if it has to be with an ideological bent, that bent should be explained

2021-01-02 17:18:20 UTC  

There is no such thing as objective history

2021-01-02 17:18:28 UTC  

Like, it was written by this dude, who won

2021-01-02 17:18:34 UTC  

So take it with a grain of salt

2021-01-02 17:18:41 UTC  

Well, history is written by winners, so yeah.

2021-01-02 17:19:31 UTC  

I’d argue that the belief in objective history is worse than not having history at all

2021-01-02 17:19:53 UTC  

It devalues the other side and forgets that what you’re being told may not be true

2021-01-02 17:20:01 UTC  

Yeah, I think that history should have some little bias, but not too much. And both sides should be shown.

2021-01-02 17:20:05 UTC  

The most important thing i was taught was to try to view history through the lense of society at the time

2021-01-02 17:20:33 UTC  

Many if the account of german tanks during ww2 were writen by nazis, the german tanks like panzer tend to do worse that T 34 , the germans won ironically because of their bigger number of tanks, this is an example were the losing side did write it but the point about taking history with a grain of salt remains

2021-01-02 17:20:36 UTC  

Yeah, we can't judge history by our modern standards. This is what liberals do wrong.

2021-01-02 17:20:44 UTC  

Like taking into consideration who writen it and such

2021-01-02 17:21:08 UTC  

They judge history by our modern day, and try to silence it, instead of judging it by that society's values and morals.

2021-01-02 17:21:30 UTC  

I just realized my writing is really a weird amalgamation of British English rules and American English rules

2021-01-02 17:21:37 UTC  

And I should work on that

2021-01-02 17:22:01 UTC  

Both sides contribute to the historical record, the winners don’t make it all on their own, but the side that won ultimately decides who will be portrayed as in the right

2021-01-02 17:22:22 UTC  

Like we view vlad the imapler as a national hero and he was a preaty good leader , and this comes from someone that would have been impaled by him for being gay , like I do get the context but I will not apologise for the wrongs he done

2021-01-02 17:22:50 UTC  

You’re Romanian?

2021-01-02 17:22:54 UTC  

Yes

2021-01-02 17:23:26 UTC  

Here in the USA Vlad the impaler is considered more of a historical villain

2021-01-02 17:23:39 UTC  

In fact he was the inspiration for Dracula

2021-01-02 17:23:54 UTC  

Yeah , but he is a national hero who fought against the turks

2021-01-02 17:24:07 UTC  

And fight against the Otoman empire is a big thing around here

2021-01-02 17:24:33 UTC  

I never thought of vlad as a villain. He just seemed desperate to protect his people

2021-01-02 17:24:37 UTC  

In a really weird way

2021-01-02 17:24:38 UTC  

And this is an example of different historical beliefs brought around from different perspectives

2021-01-02 17:25:25 UTC  

There are so many stories though, that the historical record has made a mess of.

2021-01-02 17:25:31 UTC  

Well his grandfather and gradgrandfather lose in directly fighting the otomans so he needed guerilla and intimidation tactics

2021-01-02 17:25:32 UTC  

Like the countess of bathory

2021-01-02 17:26:02 UTC  

Like, she may have killed a few people, maybe a few hundred, maybe she was a political assassination?

2021-01-02 17:26:18 UTC  

We dont know. There's no actual evidence at this point.

2021-01-02 17:26:43 UTC  

By political assassination, I mean that she was destroyed, rather than killed

2021-01-02 17:27:19 UTC  

She held lands the crown wanted

2021-01-02 17:28:20 UTC  

And now.. she is listed as one of the most prolific female serial killers 😂

2021-01-02 17:28:29 UTC  

Like natinalists and facist people keep telling that "if only vlad was alive today" and I disagree,even though he was a good leader at the time context and times have changed and his way of ruling doesn't work in the modern age

2021-01-02 17:28:40 UTC  

<@&757102104182784051> rule 11 , Lord Dummy thicc GOAT username

2021-01-02 17:28:48 UTC  

.......

2021-01-02 17:28:57 UTC  

Wtf is wrong with you?

2021-01-02 17:29:38 UTC  

No, vlads tactics were great for 1450. Not so great for 2020