Message from @meglide

Discord ID: 791083165036183552


2020-12-22 23:11:46 UTC  

My dude, we're already close to that limit.

2020-12-22 23:12:23 UTC  

You couldn’t cash out you could only sell the bond on the market, but MMT would still have to print their checks.

2020-12-22 23:12:45 UTC  

Where is your ancom meter today?

2020-12-22 23:12:55 UTC  

Still the same as always.

2020-12-22 23:13:13 UTC  

I imagine bonds that are currently marketable would be grandfathered.

2020-12-22 23:13:25 UTC  

It’s an awful idea. It only sounds good because we think the politicians would use restraint, well they have showed no restraint thus far.

2020-12-22 23:14:10 UTC  

@TaLoN132 back to our conversation ... yeah sometimes I can't tell with Robert whether he is just taking the plaintiffs side when he's reading their petition or he really believes it himself ... he does seem to think that the Supreme Court hasn't been clear on this but I think he's wrong ... @Uncivil Law helped me to understand about the standing issue and that it wasn't a mere technicality. It's a legitimate part of the law and the court is making a statement in its dimissal.

2020-12-22 23:14:24 UTC  

I have no idea what they would do. Besides bankrupt the economy.

2020-12-22 23:14:27 UTC  

Politicians that believe in MMT are more scary to me than anything because that's directly going against the idea of restraint.

2020-12-22 23:15:30 UTC  

we don't know where the limit is but we are certainly closer to it than we were yesterday

2020-12-22 23:16:34 UTC  

It will be awesome when money is worthless. It’s what all my anarchist friends have been wishing for all this time. Now the only currency is cigarettes, water and bullets. So much better

2020-12-22 23:16:37 UTC  

Generally when you cannot actually manage to dent your debt is when I'd say the ceiling is reached.

2020-12-22 23:16:47 UTC  

This happens to people all the time.

2020-12-22 23:16:52 UTC  

When they borrow too much money.

2020-12-22 23:19:50 UTC  

It’s not even the ceiling that’s the issue, it’s the faith in money that will destroy the economy. If inflation is at 10% and ever increasing you’re in trouble. Imo

2020-12-22 23:19:55 UTC  

that happened sometime ago ... maybe Nixon when he took us off the gold standard or later when Greenspan ushered in the era where deficits don't matter ... thing is the US has a money printing machine ... so it's like an ordinary person taking up counterfeiting, everything works out until folks realizes the money you're printing is fake

2020-12-22 23:20:35 UTC  

printing money doesn't actually make you more money, you understand this yes?

2020-12-22 23:20:39 UTC  

Printing money brrrr

2020-12-22 23:20:44 UTC  

makes inflation rise in response.

2020-12-22 23:20:45 UTC  

You need stable price levels. Or you are gambling against the house of hyperinflation or deflationary spirals.

2020-12-22 23:22:04 UTC  

more money, less value ... prices of goods and services adjust, eventually ... key is to be first in line where they are handing out the money, you know you are there when you bump into the politicians

2020-12-22 23:22:56 UTC  

That is extremely short-sighted and lead to what Venezuela experienced. 65 000% inflation.

2020-12-22 23:24:08 UTC  

Also you have to actually buy goods because this is fiat money.

2020-12-22 23:24:09 UTC  

no argument from me ... it's all how close you can get till you hit the knee of the exponential curve

2020-12-22 23:25:38 UTC  

It literally screws people that invest in things as well.

2020-12-22 23:25:49 UTC  

Like most things, people tend to dismiss things that are different from what they know by trying to frame the new in a way that over-simplifies the approach. MMT is not a "I can't be overdrawn because I still have checks" approach to finance.

Currency in a construct to represent value. As our economy grows so does the relative value. If there wasn't a way to introduce currency into the economy to represent the growth that has taken place, we would have whatever amount of currency that we started out with 240 years ago. How else is the growth represented.

I think this interview does a pretty good job of explaining MMT from a proponents perspective:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=28atgck_1lA

2020-12-22 23:26:42 UTC  

@TaLoN132 imagine you had theme park with your own currency. Call it M dollars. You pay your employees in M dollars and pay your bills in M dollars. Because people like to frequent your theme park people accept M dollars. Now imagine whenever had to pay new bills or employees you just printed more M dollars. Sounds good until the demand for M dollars falls. M Dollars start depreciating. It’s not like $1 to 1000 M dollars. So you need to print more. That’s MMT

2020-12-22 23:26:45 UTC  

The fact that economists treat it the same as climate change denial in the science field is a pretty good idea to me, as a layperson, to take the approach of "Well since I'm not an economist, I'll side with the economists."

2020-12-22 23:27:25 UTC  

I have read econ papers on MMT. It’s just not viable.

2020-12-22 23:28:37 UTC  

It’s not just a kind of bad idea. It’s an awful idea.

2020-12-22 23:28:59 UTC  

I think this would lead to the government stacking up assets it just prints money to buy in the short term, which literally screws everyone else out of their investments if governments can do this.

2020-12-22 23:29:13 UTC  

@TaLoN132 ignore the economic discussion for the moment and let's talk "election fraud" and where Robert's channel is headed (suggestion)

2020-12-22 23:30:03 UTC  

I don't mind someone disagreeing... I try to approach any decision I make by understanding both sides as completely as possible. That's what I valued in so many of Robert's shows when I first started watching him. He laid out both sides (or tried to given constraints) and then explained his viewpoint. I don't care that his conclusions match mine... I think laying out both sides helps people to understand that both sides of an issue can be reached by reasonable people. When only one side or viewpoint is represented, it makes those on the that side feel emboldened and the people on the other side feel diminished. It's what I hate about echo chambers and I don't need any more of them.

2020-12-22 23:30:11 UTC  

A sort of invesment crowding out effect. The Fed shouldn’t even have assets that are not us treasury notes on its balance sheet. That’s insane.

2020-12-22 23:30:22 UTC  

Agreed.

2020-12-22 23:30:34 UTC  

He'll give us a legal breadown of civil war 2.0: soyboy vs snowflake

2020-12-22 23:31:00 UTC  

This is the idea I think they're promoting, make currency, in the short term use the currency to buy liquid assets with a non-fixed value.

2020-12-22 23:31:34 UTC  

I think that SCOTUS denying on standing had a chilling effect in the legal community. Normally I would agree but there isn’t a lot of legal support for there being an argument for them to hear the case. Just my opinion

2020-12-22 23:31:45 UTC  

So as the fiat currency ends up meaning less, you still have assets that are non-fixed in international value.

2020-12-22 23:32:19 UTC  

It sounds super scammy.

2020-12-22 23:33:17 UTC  

The Fed has gone AWOL last 3 chairman’s have been elitist imo. They aren’t even suppose to prop the market up. It’s not even an original mandate. But nobody cares 😂