well, sans republic

Creating ethnic-based states is a garbage idea either way, though

Not really

eh

yeah really

especially in terms of broader ethnicities

like "Germanic" or "Slavic"

@SilverLining so your telling me states that have majority people of theyre states ethnicity are bad?

not bad, but I'm saying it's pointless to seek organization strictly upon ethnic lines

especially if it's non-existent right now

ehh i can kinda agree with that

I'd argue organization should be even more regional

but why shouldnt a state mantain its culture

For example, while the south may be "ethnically American", just like the north

I don't see why the north needs to remain tethered to the south

@SilverLining so almost like the uk

yeah... the UK needs to split up imo

theres different ethnicities within different sections

don't make "pan-[whatever]" empires

just divide as much as possible

and still even within england theirs massive accent differences

I mean, ideally, I'd want a system wherein each county/region/town has a large degree of autonomy

preferably completely democratic

problem with that

is laws would differ wildly

In a confederation, ofc

I think a constitution should be in place

as well

and it would be easy for a large group of people with a specific idealogy to all move to a specific town

to secure basic rights, at least within decent regions

eh, maybe town is too small

what about legalization of items

County, or even province/state based

i think the us is good how it is

confederacy has too many problems

and is really easy to fall apart

eh

not in modern days

@SilverLining heres a question

is the un a confederacy or federation

is the eu a confederacy or federation