Message from @Farajullah

Discord ID: 522218406297075713


2018-12-11 23:52:26 UTC  

And up until Lenin this was the case

2018-12-11 23:52:39 UTC  

Lenin early on even used the terms interchangeably

2018-12-11 23:52:42 UTC  

```a political and economic theory of social organization which advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole.```

2018-12-11 23:52:47 UTC  

advocates, owned OR regulated

2018-12-11 23:52:55 UTC  

Appeal to definition

2018-12-11 23:53:03 UTC  

it was regulated by the government that was leaning towards the community

2018-12-11 23:53:15 UTC  

and it did advocate instead of fully enforcing it, so people could still run away

2018-12-11 23:53:19 UTC  

perfectly fucking matches the example

2018-12-11 23:53:38 UTC  

yeah we can use no definitions

2018-12-11 23:53:43 UTC  

we can play with shit, that sounds fun

2018-12-11 23:53:56 UTC  

lets draw circles and quarrel whos circle is the best circle

2018-12-11 23:53:56 UTC  

ffs

2018-12-11 23:54:12 UTC  

Well you could actually read up on socialism instead of using dictionaries

2018-12-11 23:55:13 UTC  

In What is to be Done by Lenin, and Critique of the Gotha Program by Marx, you can see a clear interchangeability between socialism and communism as terms

2018-12-11 23:56:19 UTC  

It wasn't until Lenin described Marx's "First Phase of Communism" as Socialism and said it was the transition to Communism(which is what he called Marx's final phase of communism) that socialism and communism were ever used to describe different things

2018-12-11 23:56:45 UTC  

Even separating socialism and communism like that clearly demonstrates Venezuela is not socialist

2018-12-12 00:01:18 UTC  

Currently most Marxists outside of a few uneducated Marxist Leninists, use the terms interchangeably

2018-12-12 00:01:50 UTC  

And Democratic Socialists, as well as even Anarchists still agree on the final stage of communism being the goal

2018-12-12 01:08:24 UTC  

There is a clear difference between socialism and communism yes

2018-12-12 01:09:30 UTC  

Socialism is collective ownership over the means of production, while communism is a classless, moneyless and stateless world many socialists try to achieve

2018-12-12 01:09:51 UTC  

As far as I know, all Marxists are familiar with this

2018-12-12 01:11:20 UTC  

yup that's pretty spot on

2018-12-12 01:12:49 UTC  

On the topic of Venezuela, I still believe that the government of the country sticks to socialism as an ideology, and haven’t really transitioned in practice.

2018-12-12 01:34:17 UTC  

All Marxists know the terms are interchangeable, there is no clear difference

2018-12-12 01:34:34 UTC  

Socialism is classless, stateless and moneyless

2018-12-12 01:34:39 UTC  

I'll show an example

2018-12-12 01:35:21 UTC  

```Why do the anti-authoritarians not confine themselves to crying out against political authority, the state? All Socialists are agreed that the political state, and with it political authority, will disappear as a result of the coming social revolution, that is, that public functions will lose their political character and will be transformed into the simple administrative functions of watching over the true interests of society.```

2018-12-12 01:35:31 UTC  

-On Authority by Engels

2018-12-12 01:35:53 UTC  

It was commonly understood that at best communism is just the full realization of socialism

2018-12-12 01:36:10 UTC  

But communism is still socialism

2018-12-12 01:37:54 UTC  

```But these defects are inevitable in the first phase of communist society as it is when it has just emerged after prolonged birth pangs from capitalist society. Right can never be higher than the economic structure of society and its cultural development conditioned thereby.
In a higher phase of communist society, after the enslaving subordination of the individual to the division of labor, and therewith also the antithesis between mental and physical labor, has vanished; after labor has become not only a means of life but life's prime want; after the productive forces have also increased with the all-around development of the individual, and all the springs of co-operative wealth flow more abundantly – only then can the narrow horizon of bourgeois right be crossed in its entirety and society inscribe on its banners: From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs!```

2018-12-12 01:38:14 UTC  

-Critique of the Gotha Program by Marx

2018-12-12 01:38:55 UTC  

Lenin later called this first phase of communism socialism

2018-12-12 01:39:11 UTC  

And Stalin referred to the revolutionary worker state as socialism

2018-12-12 01:39:33 UTC  

Which is where the confusion lies as to what the difference between communism and socialism is

2018-12-12 01:40:45 UTC  

Simply put, socialism is at best just the broad over arching political ideas of a class less society with production held in common among all people and communism the fullest realization of it, or specifically the Marxist understanding of socialism

2018-12-12 01:40:52 UTC  

The distinction is not cut and dry

2018-12-12 01:41:05 UTC  

What is universally agreed upon is that communism is socialism

2018-12-12 01:41:10 UTC  

Everyone will agree to that

2018-12-12 01:52:27 UTC  

Currently there are zero socialist countries left except *maybe* the DPRK, but that's not something I'm confident in stating