Message from @εïз irma εïз

Discord ID: 489164633823772673


2018-09-11 19:11:43 UTC  

as far as I know communism drives towards anarchy, which is legitimately a method of exacting equality because if there is no structure and everyone is dirt poor in primitivism and anarchy then well there is no economic class

2018-09-11 19:12:05 UTC  

and true that, there can be many ways to define a class in society, intelectual capacity, practical skills, physicla prowess.

2018-09-11 19:12:21 UTC  

and id argue that those clases do exist, but to a lesser extent than say economic

2018-09-11 19:12:33 UTC  

yeah pure communism is anarchy

2018-09-11 19:12:44 UTC  

but the goal is not to make everyone dirt poor and primitive

2018-09-11 19:43:04 UTC  

Post labor society

2018-09-11 19:43:10 UTC  

Is the end goal of communism

2018-09-11 19:43:39 UTC  

huh

2018-09-11 19:43:42 UTC  

didn't know that

2018-09-11 19:43:52 UTC  

not primitivism then ig

2018-09-11 19:50:30 UTC  

Socialism is the belief that men are inherently good and equal. That it is the social stratification that causes the evils in society. So if men shared the means of production then inequality would be eliminated which would create a good society.

Social democracy tries to do the same, but by redistributing wealth through social programs.

2018-09-11 20:00:32 UTC  

Haven't I already told you repeatedly in extreme detail why this analysis of socialism is completely wrong?

2018-09-11 20:01:28 UTC  

Socialism is not "everyone is equal", this is far from a consensus in socialist theory. Socialism is collective ownership of the MOP. Even the phrase 'from each according to their ability, to each according to their need' strongly implies not everyone is equal.

2018-09-11 20:02:31 UTC  

You're confusing historical materialism that leads to the perceived injustices of capitalism with the theory of socialism itself.

2018-09-11 20:04:14 UTC  

@εïз irma εïз you haven't told me that

2018-09-11 20:04:35 UTC  

We had a very lengthy discussion where I explained why welfare capitalism is not socialism.

2018-09-11 20:04:40 UTC  

It's in the name. Welfare capitalism.

2018-09-11 20:04:54 UTC  

Yes, but you never said that

2018-09-11 20:05:18 UTC  

We never brought up the topic of equality

2018-09-11 20:05:20 UTC  

That's because I'm refuting your egalitarian reductionism of socialism, not that welfare capitalism is socialism.

2018-09-11 20:05:36 UTC  

I've already proven you wrong on one point. Now I'm proving you wrong on another.

2018-09-11 20:06:03 UTC  

Why would I repeat myself again?

2018-09-11 20:09:17 UTC  

@εïз irma εïз well perhaps I am confusing historic materialism with socialism, but that's no fault of my own as that is the philosophical roots of socialism

2018-09-11 20:09:42 UTC  

So you're confusing the problem with the solution.

2018-09-11 20:09:57 UTC  

Seems like a pretty big faux pas, and very much your fault.

2018-09-11 20:10:18 UTC  

"Redistribution of stuff" is not the end goal or Marxian socialism.

2018-09-11 20:10:37 UTC  

The inequitable distribution of stuff is a result of capitalism.

2018-09-11 20:10:45 UTC  

They're distinct ideas.

2018-09-11 20:11:00 UTC  

So whats the end goal, in your opinion

2018-09-11 20:11:24 UTC  

I'm not a Marxist, but Marx wanted a society where everyone is free to pursue their own interests.

2018-09-11 20:11:40 UTC  

And they maximize their productivity by doing what they enjoy.

2018-09-11 20:11:51 UTC  

Excess production is distributed to those who don't have.

2018-09-11 20:12:02 UTC  

That's why there is no need for a state or capital in communism.

2018-09-11 20:12:40 UTC  

Such nonsense theories

2018-09-11 20:12:46 UTC  

If rightoids really wanted to attack communism they should first actually understand it. Once you understand it instead of regurgitating boomer propaganda it's a million times easier to tear apart.

2018-09-11 20:13:20 UTC  

Socialism is not the solution to materialism, it was materialist in conception.

2018-09-11 20:13:36 UTC  

No one enjoys true labor

2018-09-11 20:13:40 UTC  

Historical materialism is a distinct concept from materialism.

2018-09-11 20:14:03 UTC  

Historical materialism is that material conditions result in stratification and exploitation.

2018-09-11 20:14:13 UTC  

Literally has nothing to do with materialism vs. spiritualism.

2018-09-11 20:14:16 UTC  

Leisure and providing for family is the only motivation for the sort of productive capacity marx describes