Message from @༺པརབྱར།བསངཇ༻
Discord ID: 347472962561114113
What is a quanifiable difference between horoscopes and MBTI so that I may determine whether or not you are making truth statements rather than value judgements?
I can't give you anything like that
the best thing would be
experience it yourself
do the test, find out your type, then read a type profile
which I will link you a few of when you do the test
then you can make up your mind how vague or specific it is
I may trust planets that have been around for billions of years and their influence on me before I trust the MBTI.
That would seem to validate my criticism.
Truth be told, I remember being impressed with the accuracy of the MBTI.
but what was your criticism @༺པརབྱར།བསངཇ༻
I don't, however, think it is some permanent assessment of me and my thinking.
it is already validated
its a permanent assessment that you are a woman
that means something about your cognition
why can there not be other similar categories?
Wait. It's a gender determiner?
it appears validated in the same sense that I might claim to be able to throw a rock into 30 foot diameter hole.
@༺པརབྱར།བསངཇ༻ what are you trying to say
that MBTI is bullshit?
Yes.
Yes, being female does mean that I think differently. So does my IQ.
I can't give you anything to make you see it is or isn't
except you going through the process
because its subjective
there may be other aspects similarly unalterable about a person
an MBTI type is a very broad thing though
I'll never be a people person, no matter how much I grow
I feel as if a sufficiently naive person visiting a palm reader would say something similar.
my 5 month old baby is obiousvly not a people person
@༺པརབྱར།བསངཇ༻ you are not coming at this the right way
you're trying to debunk
all I can say to what you say is "I guess?"
@fallot Look, I'm not trying to poo on the MBTI. I'm just not sure that its results are as immutable as you claim.
yes I understand, I dont mind if you do that anyway
what I said is, if the results are mutable
the whole thing is fundamentally worthless, nonexistent
Then I misunderstood.