Message from @Thule-Gesellschaft [☩]

Discord ID: 489937809923375105


2018-09-13 23:09:42 UTC  

bc

2018-09-13 23:10:00 UTC  

the earliest I think was written right around when Christ was around

2018-09-13 23:10:12 UTC  

there are actually Dharmic writings being written today too, but it's mostly commentary

2018-09-13 23:10:14 UTC  

Give me the date of the holy scriptures from which you extrapolate your morals for example. When were they written?

2018-09-13 23:10:15 UTC  

on the old scripture

2018-09-13 23:10:54 UTC  

@Richard Rock Rig Veda has a lot of duties. Basically monogamy, anti homosexuality, anti adultery, anti pederasty, pro large family building, anti mixing races and blood etc.

2018-09-13 23:11:13 UTC  

Okay, who exactly wrote it, when and where?

2018-09-13 23:11:36 UTC  

many many people, you can google the succession of Brahmin masters and gurus

2018-09-13 23:12:04 UTC  

Were they all deemed to be all-knowledgeable?

2018-09-13 23:12:09 UTC  

the most recent translation of the Bhagavad Gita in its authentic form was done by the last traditional Guru I know of Prabhupada

2018-09-13 23:12:28 UTC  

not all knowledgeable, but the scriptures had passed down from Surya, and other devas

2018-09-13 23:12:34 UTC  

a deva is basically an angel of God

2018-09-13 23:12:35 UTC  

a servant

2018-09-13 23:13:09 UTC  

Sir, are you tellling me that you are getting your morals from non-all knowledgeable fallable men?

2018-09-13 23:13:10 UTC  

Also the rules and duties depend on the age you live in

2018-09-13 23:13:29 UTC  

in our age, the Kali Yuga, most duties which were given to past age peoples could not even be followed because of our low lifespans

2018-09-13 23:14:01 UTC  

No, ultimately this knowledge all comes from God. The Bhagavad Gita contains within it a physical manifestation of God, who lectures the great warrior Arjuna on piety and morals.

2018-09-13 23:14:34 UTC  

The Gita is the most relevant because it is a way for us to liberate ourselves from the material illusory world in this age, the Kali Yuga or the age of wickedness and sin.

2018-09-13 23:16:49 UTC  

Did Arjuna write the Bhagavad Gita down?

2018-09-13 23:17:37 UTC  

Was he all knowledgeable, or did God, make him, by his almighty power, not forget what he was learned.

2018-09-13 23:17:56 UTC  

Sage Veda Vyasa did.

2018-09-13 23:18:34 UTC  

@Richard Rock it's by God's influence that the scriptures continue to circulate

2018-09-13 23:18:41 UTC  

Was Sage Veda Vyasa all knowledgeable?

2018-09-13 23:18:50 UTC  

no

2018-09-13 23:19:01 UTC  

From whom did he get his knowledge? Arjuna?

2018-09-13 23:20:09 UTC  

Arjuna was the Prince at the time

2018-09-13 23:20:15 UTC  

Look here, what I am looking for is this, if I ask the Christian the same questions, he will tell me that his moral guideness is the bible. The bible was a revelation inspired by God and written 2000 years ago.

2018-09-13 23:20:31 UTC  

Yes, we believe that our scriptures are divinely inspired as well

2018-09-13 23:20:37 UTC  

You seem not to want to get me a straight forward answer.

2018-09-13 23:20:59 UTC  

When was it written and by whom.

2018-09-13 23:21:06 UTC  

are you an imbecile arab?

2018-09-13 23:21:13 UTC  

I have told you there are too many names to list

2018-09-13 23:21:31 UTC  

what is the point of me listing hundreds of names?

2018-09-13 23:21:45 UTC  

Are these 100 of men all knowledgeable?

2018-09-13 23:21:48 UTC  

yes

2018-09-13 23:21:51 UTC  

At what time did they live.

2018-09-13 23:21:51 UTC  

more so than many

2018-09-13 23:21:57 UTC  

What?

2018-09-13 23:21:59 UTC  

some thousands of years ago, some more recently

2018-09-13 23:22:09 UTC  

a lot of the epics come from a time before our Kali Yuga began

2018-09-13 23:22:19 UTC  

Are they all equally knowledgeable?