Looks like you are

@Bleach Clinton imposed a luxury tax and the economy did just fine.
Rich people save their money, romoving it from circulation. A bad thing.
Poor people spend 100%. The ideal.

u said rich people remove their money from circulation...

explain how

A luxury tax != capital gains tax.

how do rich people remove their money from circulation

by investing instead of speading it

investing isnt removing it from circulation. that's the epitome of circulating money

Bullshit

how do businesses get capital to start up?

how do people get loans to buy a house?

banks need to have a reserve of cash

even in a bank ur money is being recirculated

A loan.
But a business loan is not stock or a commodities investment

all investments are used to further grow business

Corporate taxes suck

if they were putting to money into a functioning business, that would be fine.
Most store in tax havens or put their money in a commodity.

or a fund

Putting your money in a commodity or fund is investment lol

There’s nothing wrong with that

it is the Trust system in USA that is the real poison.

For example buying houses to rent

@sɪᴅɪsɴᴏᴛʜᴇʀᴇ You are removing the money from circulation when you invest in a fund or a trust.

Incorrect

It’s still in the money supply

Bullshit.
How does it make it back to the consumers hands?

It is removed from circulation.

It is locked up tight.

circulation != supply
circulation is the problem.

This is the equivalent of saying saving removes money from circulation

it does. You're supposed to spend it.

so I guess @wuzamarine you dont think a mortgage is money supply?

No, it’s in the money supply

The point is saving boosts growth

You have a simplistic view of the economy

savings boost growth the most

It's locked up in your pocket and removed from circulation.

it is the hording that is the problem.

its not in ur pocket dummy

it's in circulation. even if it's just in the bank

I’m confused to what you’re saying at.