Death of Hope is pretty good too

death of hope has good atmosphere but i hate how everything seems weightless and the sound design wasnt as good

True

Sound design is a very mixed bag

I do like how it goes back to the grimdark of older 40k

I do wish that gw would wake the fuck up and hire both of them to make something

that would be too good of them

i just hope they dont send a C&D

I know

jesus

I think that they probably wont just because its kind of a big thing

and it doesn't really paint the series in any bad light

instead it represents it pretty well

But goddam, imagine

gw money and those 2 making something in Collab

also the astartes creator is clearing $7k per month minimum based on patreon numbers, i dont think he really needs GW money

I think he uses part of the money to hire out other animators last I checked

If they just threw money at him and said "Hire who you want, do what you want, but it needs to be about this."

I think we could get a dang good thing

Death of hope was done by an artist, not an animator

He's a humble dude, I hate seeing it compared with Astartes.

was it?

damn, then he did a good job all things considered

i mean credit where its due he did better than i could do

hell yeah

One is more for the older way that 40K was and the other is more of the modern 40K

both great in their own respective ways

@Solar why do you hate seeing it compared though?

Astartes from the get go was a determined, well skilled animator. 'Wins' hands down. But Death of Hope was a drawing artist dabbling in animation, much more focused on decoration and design/theme.

Didnt know that

fuck w40k

pretty cool

Ive seen so much argument as if theyre 2 head to head competitors

they arent but they are coming out at the same time and are damn near the only two examples of better than mediocre works by fans

like it makes sense theyre being compared

Ofc, just a shame to see Death of Hope shit on so hard

True, I cant think of anything else that can really compare

i havent been seeing it get shit on

it still has a solid reception

same