Message from @Tohob

Discord ID: 483036169651879936


2018-08-25 22:08:19 UTC  

Yeah, but when I was in middle school it was all so cool ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

2018-08-25 22:08:40 UTC  

the real difference now is that these days 100% of anime reaches a western audience

2018-08-25 22:08:41 UTC  

I specifically chose the cutoff point in mid 90's, since you can definitely make the argument 70's anime is better than 70's cartoons

2018-08-25 22:08:46 UTC  

By the growing standards that come from not being a child anymore

2018-08-25 22:08:50 UTC  

80's anime better than 80's cartoons

2018-08-25 22:09:05 UTC  

when early 90's anime only ever left japan if it was already really successful

2018-08-25 22:09:28 UTC  

90's anime better than 90's cartoons... When viewed as a whole, looking at the entire industry... NOW you run into arguments

2018-08-25 22:09:38 UTC  

if anything i would say the opposite. western cartoons are what has seen a huge decline

2018-08-25 22:09:55 UTC  

while anime has remained fairly consistent in terms of overall quality

2018-08-25 22:10:31 UTC  

I could agree with that. It's nice that they're embracing continuous storylines, but most cartoons today really do suck in comparison to most of the 90's

2018-08-25 22:11:16 UTC  

There's still some quality cartoons though, but they tend to have some really weak parts to go along with the good

2018-08-25 22:11:29 UTC  

you just mentioned Gumball, it's been running for, what, 5 years? give or take? minimum 3 years but I'd hazard a guess and say 6 years

2018-08-25 22:11:43 UTC  

what anime comes even close to that?

2018-08-25 22:12:03 UTC  

lots of long running series

2018-08-25 22:12:05 UTC  

tons of them

2018-08-25 22:12:06 UTC  

Run time is what measures quality? Turns out modern Simpsons is great

2018-08-25 22:12:31 UTC  

but anime has a much bigger focus on shorter stories that can be contained and wrapped up

2018-08-25 22:12:52 UTC  

whereas western cartoons want to be able to go on forever

2018-08-25 22:13:01 UTC  

Yeah Western entertainment feels a lot more corperate to me

2018-08-25 22:13:02 UTC  

if we take out the Big Guns, we get shit like MLP that has been running for some 160 22 minute episodes across 8 years

2018-08-25 22:13:17 UTC  

and then end when it is no longer economically viable to keep producing

2018-08-25 22:13:24 UTC  

yeah that's what I was initailly getting at

2018-08-25 22:13:33 UTC  

gumball's survived this long because it's a diamond in the rough

2018-08-25 22:13:56 UTC  

and that's just how our cartoon market works out

2018-08-25 22:14:14 UTC  

Anime, also operates on a model of commissioning as series by season.

2018-08-25 22:14:19 UTC  

>gumball's survived this long because it's a diamond in the rough
this is a very good point, and sort of what I've been aiming at

2018-08-25 22:14:38 UTC  

it's an actual diamond

2018-08-25 22:15:29 UTC  

it works, because it's that one specific pile of poo that happened to be "shiny", while most piles of poo DON*T shine and therefore fail

2018-08-25 22:15:50 UTC  

it's what anime used to do in the 80's, experiment and improvise

2018-08-25 22:15:50 UTC  

Why can't we get animation like this anymore? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNho4Eze5aI
Anime just isn't the same

2018-08-25 22:16:04 UTC  

anime still does that

2018-08-25 22:16:12 UTC  

I'm sure

2018-08-25 22:16:15 UTC  

obviously not all of it, but that was never the case

2018-08-25 22:16:18 UTC  

p.s. when I said western seemed more corperate the keyword was more
not "anime is perfect! ใ‚ใ‚“ใŸใŸใกใฐใ‹ใ !", because the companies pretty regularly overwork their entire teams, but the result seems more genuine in more cases

2018-08-25 22:16:22 UTC  

yeah of course

2018-08-25 22:16:47 UTC  

but what 201X's anime compares to Gumbal, MLP?

2018-08-25 22:17:08 UTC  

idk I never watch anything when it comes out lol

2018-08-25 22:17:14 UTC  

That's too many to even know where to start

2018-08-25 22:17:37 UTC  

overlord and hinamatsuri from this year, off the top of my head

2018-08-25 22:17:57 UTC  

kakegurui's pretty new, I thought that was... *interesting*

2018-08-25 22:17:58 UTC  

if the whole 2010's is fair game i can't leave out shinsekai yori