Message from @Mr.Fisch(炫龙)

Discord ID: 701051630065549353


2020-04-18 12:17:45 UTC  
2020-04-18 12:22:28 UTC  

It's pretty obvious he's a lolbert

2020-04-18 12:22:40 UTC  

Natsoc Germany was a mixed economy period

2020-04-18 12:23:14 UTC  

Private enterprise existed, there was interventionism but it's not socialism
At least not socialism in the Marxian sense

2020-04-18 12:37:57 UTC  

Yeah, that's his point, it was racial socialism, it was national socialism and nothing with mixed econ there. Ofc it wasn't Marxist socialism

2020-04-18 12:40:34 UTC  

To even equate those is retarded. Having a few corporations nationalized or follow certain guidelines with intervention into the market is not racial socialism if you want to compare it to Marxian socialism
Since Marxian socialism demands the economy be holistically in control of the workers' state
National socialism had a mixed economic model aka state capitalism

2020-04-18 12:41:07 UTC  

Mixing up these terms to throw dirt at socialists doesn't work and makes you look like someone with a room temperature IQ

2020-04-18 12:42:00 UTC  

Obviously, you didn't look up the facts or even looking at the facts which TIK presented to you on a silver plate

2020-04-18 12:43:10 UTC  

I've watched the video before. It doesn't matter Hitler called himself a socialist when social democrats at the time did the same and he purged the Strasserists from his ranks

2020-04-18 12:43:24 UTC  

Nazi Germany was about as socialist as China is now

2020-04-18 12:44:04 UTC  

Yeah, China is also becoming more socialist at the time, stil didn't reach the level of the 3rd Reich yet

2020-04-18 12:44:20 UTC  

As well as the EUSSR

2020-04-18 12:44:31 UTC  

>the EUSSR

2020-04-18 12:44:49 UTC  

The libertarian to alt right pipeline was a mistake

2020-04-18 12:45:54 UTC  

LoL, at least Libertarians have an alternative and working system instead of replacing the old one with a new one of old type

2020-04-18 12:45:57 UTC  

😂

2020-04-18 12:46:35 UTC  

Libertarians alread get 80+% of what they want under neoliberalism and it's horrendous

2020-04-18 12:46:54 UTC  

I doubt the last 20% are going to turn out well either

2020-04-18 12:47:57 UTC  

If you mean money socialism, more centralization, more regulation, more war mongering and imperialism, I think not

2020-04-18 12:48:31 UTC  

Do you think we're more or less socialist then in the 50s

2020-04-18 12:48:53 UTC  

Depends on the country

2020-04-18 12:48:59 UTC  

In Germany by far, yes

2020-04-18 12:49:45 UTC  

In most other countries probably about the same with some volatility and ups and downs

2020-04-18 12:50:00 UTC  

If anything countries have become economically more liberal than at any other point in history

2020-04-18 12:50:14 UTC  

Do you think Macron made France less liberal

2020-04-18 12:50:34 UTC  

No, not under laissez-faire markets under Victorian rule oder inside the German Kaiser Reich

2020-04-18 12:50:59 UTC  

The Kaiserreich had a welfare state and strict regulations

2020-04-18 12:51:15 UTC  

What do you mean by liberal? The real sense of the word or the nowadays meaning?

2020-04-18 12:51:17 UTC  

Victorian England was a mercantile empire

2020-04-18 12:51:34 UTC  

The single most impactfull liberalization happened regarding trade

2020-04-18 12:51:45 UTC  

The GATT and WTO being introduced

2020-04-18 12:51:52 UTC  

> The Kaiserreich had a welfare state and strict regulations
@Mr. Nessel
Due to more and more regulations and interventions. Not in the beginning, and even after the state quota remained pretty low

2020-04-18 12:52:17 UTC  

> The GATT and WTO being introduced
@Mr. Nessel
That's not freedom, that's supra governmental regulation

2020-04-18 12:52:24 UTC  

Bismarck was forced to create the welfare state relatively early on

2020-04-18 12:52:43 UTC  

remember Germany only became a country in the 1870s

2020-04-18 12:53:02 UTC  

Yes, that was the problem in the first place

2020-04-18 12:53:07 UTC  

The GATT and WTO forced people to have free trade

2020-04-18 12:53:16 UTC  

That's not free trade

2020-04-18 12:53:21 UTC  

It is

2020-04-18 12:53:31 UTC  

Because it lowered tariffs across the board

2020-04-18 12:53:33 UTC  

That's just convergence of regulations