civil-debate

Discord ID: 538929818834698260


127,199 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev | Page 289/1272 | Next

2019-05-06 13:21:26 UTC

when u look at the horizon

2019-05-06 13:21:39 UTC

jsut like the floor in the hallway rises up its perspective

*see pinned messages (VIDEOS)

2019-05-06 13:22:29 UTC

Oh, that's what you mean by *rise up*

๐Ÿ’ก ding

2019-05-06 13:22:41 UTC

what do u think rising up means

2019-05-06 13:22:45 UTC

appears to be above

2019-05-06 13:22:48 UTC

higher than

2019-05-06 13:23:07 UTC

It's a weird way to describe *converging towards the eye level*

2019-05-06 13:23:34 UTC

well the water is coming from ur feet then going up toward ur eye level

2019-05-06 13:23:39 UTC

i call that rising up

2019-05-06 13:23:56 UTC

appearing to rise up

2019-05-06 13:24:31 UTC

we know its not really rising up though and the water is actually beneath ur feet so the first thing we see at the ocean is an illusion due to perspective

2019-05-06 13:24:46 UTC

Yes, but the water isn't *rising* anywhere. Because of perspective, the line of sight between you and the water converges towards your line of sight, meeting in infinity. That's what we call the *vanishing point*

2019-05-06 13:25:53 UTC

thats waht i said appears to be rising

2019-05-06 13:25:58 UTC

thats why i said

2019-05-06 13:26:10 UTC

we know its not rising it is actually beneath ur feet

2019-05-06 13:27:00 UTC

i wasnt talking about why i was jsut talking about what u see we know why it happens

2019-05-06 13:27:16 UTC

I mean sure but it's just a really weird way of describing it, there's better words you could use. Just look at that hallway pic Mike posted. The floor is *converging* towards your line of sight, it's not really *rising up*.

2019-05-06 13:27:28 UTC

it appears to be rising up

2019-05-06 13:27:33 UTC

It's just semantics, but it's important semantics

2019-05-06 13:27:54 UTC

does the water at the ocean appear to be flat lowering or rising up ?

2019-05-06 13:28:14 UTC

It appears to be *converging* towards your line of sight.

2019-05-06 13:28:20 UTC

You know what converging means, right?

2019-05-06 13:28:23 UTC

which would be up from ur feet?

2019-05-06 13:28:30 UTC

down from ur feet or flat from ur feet?

2019-05-06 13:28:53 UTC

its going from the bottom of ur feet up to ur eyeline

2019-05-06 13:29:23 UTC

thats what u see

2019-05-06 13:29:44 UTC

Wh..I mean *yes* but it's still level *to* your feet, so using the phrase *rising up* can be ambiguous and confusing

2019-05-06 13:29:52 UTC

That's why you use *converge*

2019-05-06 13:29:57 UTC

its confusing cause we are seeing an illusion

2019-05-06 13:30:07 UTC

Since it's the correct word to use when talking about optics

2019-05-06 13:30:09 UTC

we know its not rising up like it appears to be

2019-05-06 13:30:20 UTC

*Dude are you reading what I'm saying*?

2019-05-06 13:30:24 UTC

the water appears to be higher than your feet

2019-05-06 13:30:28 UTC

yes i see what ur saying

2019-05-06 13:30:46 UTC

have u ever stood at the beach and looked into the ocean

2019-05-06 13:31:10 UTC

Yes I have, but that's irrelevant here, I'm commenting on your usage of words to describe phenomenon

2019-05-06 13:31:23 UTC

does the water appear to be 1. above 2 below 3. right at your feet

2019-05-06 13:31:29 UTC

pick one

2019-05-06 13:31:48 UTC

its the way u see it

2019-05-06 13:31:58 UTC

It *appears* to be "above" my feet.

2019-05-06 13:32:01 UTC

ok

2019-05-06 13:32:13 UTC

why u use quotes

2019-05-06 13:32:18 UTC

above is above

2019-05-06 13:32:25 UTC

Because it's not *actually* above my feet.

2019-05-06 13:32:37 UTC

we know its not actually above we are just talking about what u see

2019-05-06 13:32:43 UTC

u see it appear to be above ur feet

2019-05-06 13:32:53 UTC

*Yes*

2019-05-06 13:32:56 UTC

we know its not actually above ur feet

2019-05-06 13:32:58 UTC

jesus

2019-05-06 13:33:10 UTC

are u a globe believer

2019-05-06 13:33:52 UTC

I am, but I like to challenge every view, and more importantly correct incorrect science on both sides.

2019-05-06 13:34:28 UTC

ok well now we have established the water appears to be above your feet at the ocean but we know it isnt the first thing we see when looking out into the ocean is not true to what is really happenning

2019-05-06 13:34:42 UTC

would u say the observation of the water appearing to be above ou r feet matcehs reality ?

2019-05-06 13:34:52 UTC

matches reality ?

2019-05-06 13:35:05 UTC

It depends on what you mean by *matching reality*

2019-05-06 13:35:59 UTC

The fact that the water surface converges towards your line of sight is simply a byproduct of how perspective works.

2019-05-06 13:36:28 UTC

So by those standards, yes, trigonometry does indeed match reality

2019-05-06 13:39:53 UTC

we see the water appearing to be above our feet does that observation match reality reality meaning is the water actually above our feet

2019-05-06 13:40:11 UTC

idk what reality means to u to me it means what is happening in real life

2019-05-06 13:40:37 UTC

we are jsut talking is what u see is what is real

2019-05-06 13:41:35 UTC

Matching reality would in his case mean that the water being above our feet would be *factually correct*, which, no, it isn't factually correct, as it's a visual phenomenon that's happening. It's real in the sense that it's what we expect to see due to perspective, but it's not *factually* happening.

2019-05-06 13:41:53 UTC

not talking about why or math or angles or perspective.

2019-05-06 13:42:05 UTC

just is what we see real is the water really above ur feet

2019-05-06 13:42:44 UTC

The mathematics here is what explains it though. No, the water isn't above our feet. It just appears to be because of mathematics

2019-05-06 13:42:57 UTC

dont need an explenation or reaason why it happens

2019-05-06 13:43:08 UTC

we know why it appears that way

2019-05-06 13:43:16 UTC

..you don't want to know why something happens?

2019-05-06 13:43:30 UTC

im trying to find out if what we see is real

2019-05-06 13:43:40 UTC

the first observation out to sea isnt

2019-05-06 13:43:46 UTC

because the water isnt above our feet in real life

2019-05-06 13:43:47 UTC

That's a bit..sad my dude, no offense.

2019-05-06 13:43:50 UTC

?

2019-05-06 13:44:05 UTC

we know how perspective works

2019-05-06 13:44:26 UTC

im trying to figure out if our observations when we look out to sea are real or not

2019-05-06 13:44:39 UTC

because when we see too far thats an illusion also thats not real

2019-05-06 13:44:57 UTC

You're trying to figure out if the water is actually above our feet..?

2019-05-06 13:45:01 UTC

idk why its sad im trying to figure out if the observation is real

2019-05-06 13:45:08 UTC

does the observation match whats really happenning

2019-05-06 13:45:28 UTC

cause the boats going over the curve and the fact we see too far is important

2019-05-06 13:46:16 UTC

Uhm

2019-05-06 13:46:49 UTC

I'm having trouble following you. Are you trying to figure out whether it *seems* like the water is rising, or whether it's *actually* rising?

2019-05-06 13:48:59 UTC

Sorry I was trying to make an easy point but then I had someone last night argue with me for hours that the water does appear to be above our feet

2019-05-06 13:49:18 UTC

I'm not sure how they came to that conclusion.

2019-05-06 13:49:36 UTC

They either misunderstood you, or they don't understand perspective.

2019-05-06 13:50:26 UTC

So would u say thatโ€™s an illusion when u see the water above your feet

2019-05-06 13:50:56 UTC

I'm not entirely sure that illusion is the best word here, but for the sake of the argument, yes.

2019-05-06 13:51:36 UTC

U see something but itโ€™s not real is that an illusion

2019-05-06 13:51:55 UTC

*I guess*

2019-05-06 13:52:28 UTC

Maybe *optical illusion* would be a bit better

2019-05-06 13:53:02 UTC

ilยทluยทsion
/iหˆloอžoZHษ™n/
noun
a thing that is or is likely to be wrongly perceived or interpreted by the senses.

2019-05-06 13:53:20 UTC

seeing is a sense

2019-05-06 13:53:31 UTC

we are perceiving the water above our feet

2019-05-06 13:53:33 UTC

Yeah, okay, that's a good point

2019-05-06 13:53:36 UTC

its isnt above our feet

2019-05-06 13:54:09 UTC

so is the first thing we see at the ocean which is the water above our feet an illusion

127,199 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev | Page 289/1272 | Next