same, i never got that summary earlier

Wait. It would be good for both sides to summarize their points

Besides even if judicial review was in the constitution

@Misomania yeah, I chose the 1st because it also has two other clauses relevant to the example

It's still too much fucking power for 9 unelected officials

Luckily it's not and can be curb stomped

here we go again with the "judicial review" boogeyman

actually the reason for it is because it would make the supreme court completely useless

you give me permission to boil pasta, and now you're upset I'm boiling macaroni

I don't find this mode of debate helpful

Be back in a few

come on you two i know you guys can be civil

"the word 'macaroni' doesn't appear _anywhere_ in my letter of permission for you to boil pasta"

The court was meant to be useless, it was meant to delegate between 2 parties as an unbiased 3rd party

> the court was meant to be useless

What part of the constitution says, "review by the US Supreme Court of the constitutional validity of a legislative act."

the part where the U.S. is a party

in any question concerning the constitutionality of a legislative act

I need exact words

Not implied phrases

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articleiii

read it a couple times

I have

It's not in there

now try to imagine you're not somebody arguing against the institution's purpose

because clearly that's not what the authors of article III meant

a judicial review isn't really all that powerful anyway iirc, to stop one branch they need the agreement (or at least passivity) of the 3rd branch. If both agreed against the judicial branch then they get their say instead

and you'll understand how cases where the U.S. is a party, including all questions about legislation, are subject to the judicial power

executive orders though.... god damn they expanded that to much

Where does it say that

section 2

just read it, please

don't say you read it

I have

actually read it

no, you haven't

oh yea you can basically do anything with an EO

It's not written there

Its implied

I dont believe in implied powers

...