But that does not help when you do not have the transport to get the grain where it need to go

Siberia for example

Thats where the central state steps in

tribalism

Yes and look at how well of a job they did

Or regionalism

did well for germany

As well since they only care about their local groups. Then national defense is out

Just a bunch of fiefdom armies

National defence would be task for the central state

They needed to eat something

So people it was

There wouldnt be one. As they would be to busy with their small fiefs and not care about the central state. As well a central state would nullify communism and breed another stalin, mao, or pol pot

Basically the state would take care of infrastructure, defence, justice and police, and thr regions of production

Stalin existed because he was nessesary

Not very marxist

And again the central being in charge of the defense and infrastructure just means an opening for human nature to want more

Critical theory goes out the window when you have to fight to exist

Even most marxist admitted this during ww2

The wants of the proletariat would be put on the list of needs and evaluate their importance collectivelly

Ie need a new car or need a need tractor, tractor would ve chosen

So heirarchy is ok if it means you have to fight to survive?

Hierarchy is anti communist

You just created a class

one who dictates where resources are better suited

Hierarchy will always be present in society, it's ridiculous to argue against it

A military class whos labor everyone exploits

So how can you have a classless society?

An opening for a bright eyed general to exploit

There would be the worker class, the bureaucratic class, the judiciary class and military (drafted civilians)

So there are not officers in the military?

Officers and lower enlisted

Do drafted armies not have officers?

They would not be drafted

You just said communism was classless

Officers are never draftees

Most of the time

Officers are taken through volunteers that undergo military academic training

It does happen on occasions

Very rare