The fuck do you think a nation is kid?

Catalonia was just a fucking enclave that existed for a few years and they just murdered people

A nation-state is an entity with the monopoly of violence in any given area which proscribes laws and rules

They did not just murder people wtf?

You know history?

Holy shit kek

They were a fully functioning society

"We do not wish to deny that the nineteenth of July brought with it an overflowing of passions and abuses, a natural phenomenon of the transfer of power from the hands of privileged to the hands of the people. It is possible that our victory resulted in the death by violence of four or five thousand inhabitants of Catalonia who were listed as rightists and were linked to political or ecclesiastical reaction."

The nature of revolution is definitly violent

A murder pit that collapsed after less than a decade isnt a success you retard

Are you insane

Five thousand people out of 2 million?

The United States kills more people than that for various crimes and reasons every day

Top kek

Oh really?

Probs

There were no trials for the murders in catalonia retard

Dafuq

yeah there were retard

You would have gotten your brains bashed in by a bum with a hammer

You upper class millenial

Smart ad hominem

you have a real argument against a classless, moneyless society?

mutual aid and communes become the norm

and guess what

you get to work less

and enjoy more

Capitalism exploits you for your labor

and the left offers you it back

Ok fren. Who owns the factory?

And the machines

The syndicate of the factor

factory*

The workers own it themselves

democratically

Who manages the voting?

Who needs too?

Do they get compensation?

Are you retarded? Someone has to take the votes and hold the election

They need no compensation, the commune provides for all

There are such things as direct elections