That is proof

Not ideas

Materialist proof infact

Nope

Strawman

>saying words is an idea

i dont think so

That's an idea

It’s scientifically proven that material existed before life

Life creates ideas

Material creates ideal

You asked me for physical proof for God; I'm requesting physical proof for materialism being the ultimate truth

That's not physical proof

This is physical proof

How so?

The earth is literally physical proof you retard

The Earth is physical proof for what?

Humans and life has not been around as long as the earth

And life is what creates ideas

Therefore, material predates ideal

So a microorganism can create ideas?

no he means sentient beings

A microorganism hasn’t been around as long as the earth

Where did life come from?

Earth is what created life, which then creates ideas

No physical proof, sorry

Dumbass doesn’t know what physical means

9/11 was CGI

No physical proof

>Earth is not physical
Fascist logic

I never said Earth wasn't physical

Earth is immaterial

https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/ast.2017.1700

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6072078/

Your ideology of atheism is based on nothing but flat-Earth logic

Jewish lies

Mars also is an example

Mars has no life

Mars therefore has no ideas

we can only trust 4chan and reddit for viable information

Prove it