Message from @Dr Badass PhD

Discord ID: 795478903707402302


2021-01-03 22:48:33 UTC  

Most ships today are very thinly armored

2021-01-03 22:48:34 UTC  

That is cool

2021-01-03 23:48:33 UTC  

That's awesome

2021-01-03 23:49:17 UTC  

Modern day anti-ship missiles at least to my knowledge aren't made to penetrate armor.

2021-01-03 23:53:04 UTC  

IJN Musashi survived 17 bomb and 19 torpedo hits before going under.

2021-01-04 01:12:09 UTC  

The only reason a modern Destroyer would win against a WW2 era battleship is due to the fact that they have the accuracy to disable, not sink, a battleship

2021-01-04 01:21:28 UTC  

Yeah

2021-01-04 01:22:23 UTC  

A destroyer would see a battleship long before the battleship could see the destroyer. And thus the destroyer can control the means of engagement.

2021-01-04 01:56:35 UTC  

how would it disable it if it can't penetrate it

2021-01-04 01:57:27 UTC  

The reason anti-ship missiles aren't made to penetrate armor is because no ship today has armor

2021-01-04 01:58:12 UTC  

Also an Iowa Class battleship has about 4x the range of a modern Arleigh Burke Class destroyer. It could literally run the destroyer down.

2021-01-04 01:58:53 UTC  

Not to mention the battleships used since WW2 have CIWS, missiles (anti-ship, anti-air, and sea to ground), radar, and are not slow ships.

2021-01-04 02:01:19 UTC  

Oh btw the Iowa Class still has its original WW2 fire control system because it's ridiculously accurate for dropping 2 ton shells 20+ miles away

2021-01-04 02:24:36 UTC  

Hitting it in the bridge, funnels etc is disabling it. That would by no means take it out though.

2021-01-04 02:26:20 UTC  

I think both ships survive the engagement at long range.

2021-01-04 02:26:53 UTC  

At ranges closer than let's say 50 miles, and the battleship wins hands down.

2021-01-04 02:27:08 UTC  

missiles target ships, not parts of ships

2021-01-04 02:27:50 UTC  

also the conning tower of a battleship has up to a foot and half of armor

2021-01-04 02:28:05 UTC  

they were made to take hits from other battleships

2021-01-04 02:28:43 UTC  

Ooh yeah that's true.

2021-01-04 02:29:09 UTC  

The destroyer would get hits logically in the softer areas.

2021-01-04 02:29:29 UTC  

But the battleship isn't significantly damaged.

2021-01-04 02:29:38 UTC  

At long range.

2021-01-04 02:30:21 UTC  

At short range? That's one dead destroyer. A single salvo is enough to take it out

2021-01-04 02:30:54 UTC  

rocket destroyer

2021-01-04 02:31:13 UTC  

is there a different name for that

2021-01-04 02:34:08 UTC  

I don't know 🤔

2021-01-04 02:35:47 UTC  

Not the hull necessarily, it can technically still target the bridge and fire control

2021-01-04 02:36:22 UTC  

Which are both the most armored parts of the ship

2021-01-04 02:36:51 UTC  

anti ship missiles are made to hit thinly armored modern ships

2021-01-04 02:37:31 UTC  

Not something that was built to take other battleships on head to head

2021-01-04 02:37:44 UTC  

On another note

2021-01-04 02:37:47 UTC  

I did a thing

2021-01-04 02:38:00 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/722683196373991506/795481125123784704/image0.jpg

2021-01-04 02:38:00 UTC  

i mean, a Torpedo from a biplane was enough to completely disable the Atlantics biggest battleship

2021-01-04 02:38:21 UTC  

technically only the steering but yeah

2021-01-04 02:39:06 UTC  

So basically I did as the Germans do and slapped the dual 128 mm as Guns on an unfinished M46 chassis I had lying around

2021-01-04 02:39:16 UTC  

nice

2021-01-04 02:39:56 UTC  

Only problem is, the guns can’t elevate as high as they usually would have been able to on an actual mount

2021-01-04 02:40:45 UTC  

@Zilla that’s torpedos

2021-01-04 02:40:47 UTC  

Not missiles