Message from @The Big Oof
Discord ID: 488131628552421386
Why should people be loyal to nations?
I'm pointing out how your argument makes no sense when taken to its logical conslusion
Unless you're just arguing that xenophobia is a good thing
Except you haven't, you introduce a new point and then argue against my perceived response, and when I respond, you're already halfway through arguing with yourself, so now I have to repeat that again, rinse and repeat
Seems like my characterization of you was ironically correct
Go ahead and answer why one should be loyal to nations, then
I'll wait.
but I don't really see how
You view the world in black and white where there can only be your position or a different one
Bad wording ^
on my part
*There can only be your position or an "evil" one
That's not true at all
See, what you said
It clearly is
implied that a nation should only consist of those who "identify" with it
False
false
\
many domestic citizens don't "identify" with said nation
false
false
True.
false
false
false
okay
I didn't say that
What did you intend to imply, then?
"Why does it matter if you have people in your country that don't identify with it"
seems to imply that countries should only harbor those who identify with it
I said you should not invite foreigners as they usually do not identify with your nation
There will always be some of your own people who do not identify with your nation, and that's fine,but does that mean you should add to that number?
Let's say
you have 100 million people in Bullshitland
your original comment didn't even remotely seem to imply that
you can presumably understand where my opinion came from
It didn't imply that, because you never asked me about it
Instead of asking what my position was
"Well then, what about your own people who hate your country?"
for exa,ple