@Павло/Pavlo it wasn't socialist or communist

I am not saying the USSR was communist in 1921. At all. I'm just using the term historians use for the sake of conversation.

well it is a contradiction

i'm pretty sure the ussr was socialist

And if you paid attention to the context of the conversation you'd know that.

socialism and communism are one in same, socialism being the economic system

But you are just a cringey pseudointellectual so you didn't.

Now fuck off.

war communism didn't exist

lolol

socialism and communism are not the same

The ewntire left are Commies

that's false

fake news!

war communism is a non idea

despite what my profile pic says

look at their agendas

call it something else

like you know

jewry

You are saying war communism never existed because at that stage of the USSR it wasn't "true communism" (as outlined by Marx) and is therefore contradictory. This is a poor strawman, as the term more refers to the official ideology of the Bolsheviks rather than a more thorough analysis of Marxism.

it isn't a poor strawman because war communism is literally a non existant idea

it was a linearized western dubbing of the phenomenon

to further exemplify false ideas of communism

It was literally a stage in the USSR's history that happened.

no, the USSR didn't call it war communism

We call lots of things that weren't originally called those things. Your point?

i am simply attacking the name by the way

"True Communism" cannot exist unless you take humanity out of humans

pavlo youre an idiot

I can hardly imagine America's monetary policies today have a clear name TODAY, but a century down the road historians will inevitably talk about it and give it a name.

Just like we have done to war communism.

So your entire argument is moronic.

that's a common argument @Павло/Pavlo but please explain

i've already told you why it was inaccurate

and today's monetary policies do have a clear name

And I have already explained why your reasoning is flawed.

so you're being a little redundant

Are you bait or genuinely retarded? If you're the former I'll get back to my reading.

it's named how it is to further exemplify the incorrectness of the western world's definition of communism

that's all it is for