Message from @Norik

Discord ID: 693627360267993189


2020-03-29 00:52:45 UTC  

And afaik Hobbes was ambivalent about monarchy/republic

2020-03-29 00:52:46 UTC  

Yes but that’s not how he uses it

2020-03-29 00:52:53 UTC  

Arguing against rebellion

2020-03-29 00:53:06 UTC  

Rather than for any given system

2020-03-29 00:53:38 UTC  

So Hobbes would say to a North Korean to not resist

2020-03-29 00:54:19 UTC  

“Common wealth” = all sovereignty combined into a united whole

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/668949999547318272/693624045010419792/image0.jpg

2020-03-29 00:54:22 UTC  

Machiavelli isn't really idealistic but realistic too so idk what is meant with a Machiavellian principality

2020-03-29 00:54:26 UTC  

Notice how the chain mail is the subjects of the king

2020-03-29 00:54:39 UTC  

Technically any principality is Machiavellian

2020-03-29 00:54:45 UTC  

And so is any state

2020-03-29 00:55:02 UTC  

Because all operate under Realpolitik

2020-03-29 00:56:14 UTC  

i thought it was a bunch of scales at first

2020-03-29 00:56:42 UTC  

and i was like "oh leviathan is a big fish and this king has a bunch of scales like a fish"

2020-03-29 00:58:00 UTC  

I think the illustration explains his argument pretty clearly

2020-03-29 00:59:16 UTC  

The king holds both temporal/legal authority (the sword) and ecclesiastical authority (the scepter) but only as long as he truly represents and acts on behalf of his people

2020-03-29 01:00:31 UTC  

(Otherwise there’s civil wars and revolutions and shit, like the civil war in England which prompted Hobbes to write the Leviathan in the first place)

2020-03-29 01:01:17 UTC  

I think fascism/Pinochetism are technically Hobbesian in a sense

2020-03-29 01:02:14 UTC  

Since they consist of the nation agreeing to cede authority to a single leader with the expectation of order above all else

2020-03-29 01:06:33 UTC  

why does he call it leviathan

2020-03-29 01:07:26 UTC  

*Heheh, Hobbes one arguement to help support Anglicanism*.

2020-03-29 01:07:29 UTC  

Reference to the biblical monster

2020-03-29 01:07:46 UTC  

Because the subjects live in awe and fear of the king

2020-03-29 01:08:10 UTC  

In a way which inspires obedience/allegiance

2020-03-29 01:09:08 UTC  

*Nationlize reilgion*.

2020-03-29 01:09:13 UTC  

It’s a really worthwhile read as a defense of monarchy, I’m not sure I agree with it but I still highly recommend it

2020-03-29 01:10:36 UTC  

Hm, Norik? are there Physcial copies?.

2020-03-29 01:11:08 UTC  

Or should i just read a PDF verson?.

2020-03-29 01:15:47 UTC  

<:GWcmeisterPeepoShrug:403295315685539852>

2020-03-29 01:16:18 UTC  

I prefer physical books always but if you don’t mind a pdf then I don’t think it matters

2020-03-29 01:18:01 UTC  

Wait could you please link, a cite that i can use to purqure a physical verson.

2020-03-29 01:21:10 UTC  

Amazon dot com

2020-03-29 01:21:18 UTC  

It’s a famous book lol

2020-03-29 01:21:48 UTC  

Leviathan by Thomas Hobbes

2020-03-29 01:21:57 UTC  

Mhm.

2020-03-29 01:22:21 UTC  

Anyway none of these answers help me write my essay lmao

2020-03-29 01:23:04 UTC  

What is the essay on?.

2020-03-29 01:23:20 UTC  

Is it on the question you stated earlier?.

2020-03-29 01:23:24 UTC  

Yes

2020-03-29 01:23:56 UTC  

You’re exiled and your only options for fleeing are a Machiavellian principality or a Hobbesian commonwealth

2020-03-29 01:24:07 UTC  

Where do you go and why

2020-03-29 01:24:32 UTC  

What facotor's need to be inculded?.