i'm only familiar with the expropriation of the commons in europe, how did it happen here?

it didn't

Capitalism isnt a global system now?

we never had any commons

Interesting.

It did

yes capitalism is global

They werent called commons

but we are talkign about nations

Because the colonials rolled in

they didn't exist

oh fuck the native americans you are takling about

And just slaughtered the native peoples

And took the land

we gave them smallpox and they all died

that's how that happened yeah

And shot them, and waged war

For land

And resources.

that's not capitaism

Except it is.

that's jsut killingpeople and taking shit

you country will be founded the same way

capitalism was built on that foundation

Why do you think columbus set out for his voyage to india

For capital

your theoretical country of communal land

how do you think you are gonig to get it?

It was only his luck he rolled into the americas

from my cold dead hands that's how

Well yes literally.

But again

right

Covered that.

So.

you are no better

Except we are

how?

Seeing as how our violence isnt to supplement a global majority

you are going to kill everyone and take there shit

lol

what does that mean?

That has the power to cure just about every worldly disease, end world hunger, and poverty.

It'd be a movement for people instead of a ruling class

And, the violence would be vastly diminished

Seeing as how there wouldnt be any reason to wage foreign wars

howver you justify it you woudl still ahve to go in and take some other peoples land and kill them

For "muh freedoms"

There'd be a vast decrease in crime

you are takling about waging a war

No, im talking about revolution

no war but class war

Quite a bit different

yeah revolution is a type of war

that's just a civil war

Except it isnt

except it is

Its literally just an upheaval of the current social order

I'm not giving my land to you without a fight

and I have guns

You might not,

Others will

But the point is

no they won't

lol

A few people dying isnt a war

what land owners have you talked to

yes, it is

we can get guns too.
easier than acquiring land, actually

And they didnt in the USSR?

that's the definiteon of war

Really?

this ain't the USSR

NOBODY voluntarily gave up land?

Interesting

it's the united states of america

How about spain?

How about germany?

we all have guns

How about ukraine?

why are you still naming other countries

You're what you'd call "bullshit"

big ups to your banner.
makhno was so cool

There is no exceptional class of americans who somehow wouldnt be privy to cooperation

yes, there are

People will both fight, and cooperate

As they do

people will fight you

Literally everywhere

the cooperation you describe in these other nations was by force

FORCE

Or just people uniting behind an idea

Because you know,

People do that

yes, people uniting to forcefully take shit from other people

they do do that

Yes

Under capitalism

And every other system

Ever