Message from @Leiro レイロ

Discord ID: 513341477640732683


2018-11-17 13:06:52 UTC  

@Leiro レイロ But so much of the economy these days doesn't have a "means of production"

2018-11-17 13:07:10 UTC  

Like, we're not all Soviet workers in foundries and forges anymore.

2018-11-17 13:07:16 UTC  

lets just fucking shoot trump

2018-11-17 13:07:18 UTC  

There's not always a piece of machinery to own.

2018-11-17 13:07:33 UTC  

what do you mean, don't have a means of production? Literally most capital is owned by the bourgeois capitalists

2018-11-17 13:07:40 UTC  

Means of production isn't only machines

2018-11-17 13:07:40 UTC  

nowdays

2018-11-17 13:07:54 UTC  

MOP dosent necessarily mean tools or machines

2018-11-17 13:08:17 UTC  

you seem to have a common misconception of socialism

2018-11-17 13:08:24 UTC  

looks like I gotta get rid of that

2018-11-17 13:09:41 UTC  

and yes @HaplessOperator it's also a misconception that everyone earns the same, don't believe that shit.

2018-11-17 13:10:30 UTC  

So, say, for an agency like... Boeing, for example

2018-11-17 13:10:36 UTC  

What would the means of production be

2018-11-17 13:12:14 UTC  

ur mom

2018-11-17 13:13:05 UTC  

Well for boeing, it would be anyone who works for boeing

2018-11-17 13:13:24 UTC  

like aerospace engineers and more

2018-11-17 13:14:15 UTC  

oh wait I misinterpreted

2018-11-17 13:14:28 UTC  

it would be the capital owned by boeing, as well as all facilities and such

2018-11-17 13:15:18 UTC  

Workstations, laptops, radios...

2018-11-17 13:15:40 UTC  

The guns, working dogs...

2018-11-17 13:15:45 UTC  

Well yes, but they may not necessarily be owned by boeing itself if their personal property

2018-11-17 13:15:50 UTC  

guns and dogs?

2018-11-17 13:16:19 UTC  

What about the ambulances and medical equipment.

2018-11-17 13:16:34 UTC  

And the fire trucks.

2018-11-17 13:17:01 UTC  

they would be owned by the respective agency, unless their facilities have inhouse medical equipment and fire trucks

2018-11-17 13:17:18 UTC  

It is in-house, yes.

2018-11-17 13:17:25 UTC  

Same with the guns and working dogs.

2018-11-17 13:17:54 UTC  

Well then, they would be owned communally then, nobody is able to take that privately for themselves

2018-11-17 13:18:06 UTC  

laptops may be personal property

2018-11-17 13:18:12 UTC  

Couldn't be.

2018-11-17 13:18:28 UTC  

Security measures would basically preclude that in any way.

2018-11-17 13:18:47 UTC  

There's sensitive, *sensitive* shit at those facilities.

2018-11-17 13:18:51 UTC  

Well, yea.

2018-11-17 13:18:58 UTC  

so what other questions do you have?

2018-11-17 13:19:24 UTC  

So how does that mesh, when you run into shit that cannot be communally owned or handled due to its very nature

2018-11-17 13:19:36 UTC  

things like?

2018-11-17 13:19:57 UTC  

Like the laptops. And guns. Basically anything that would be serialized gear.

2018-11-17 13:20:35 UTC  

laptops will be your own personal property, while for guns if their company guns then no.

2018-11-17 13:20:51 UTC  

But we already established that the laptops couldn't work like that.

2018-11-17 13:21:03 UTC  

You couldn't take this sort of thing home.

2018-11-17 13:21:10 UTC  

but really, laptops are kind of vague really, they arent a MOP and we don't want to collectivise them