@AdorableStormtrooper just a sec I'll post it

it's almost as if rapid industrialization is innately destructive or something and exacerbating the effects by eradicating the food production class is utterly retarded

@Aki but it wasn't intentional

that's the argument

@Stern so the exports decline post collectivization, wew lad

they had to pay for the foreign goods

>intentional eradication of farmers
>not intentional

never could have guessed that

raw mental gymnastics

@Alois Hello and welcome

Well firstly when you say that the amount of Grain exports decreased well... what is it supposed to prove?

hello @Bearer Of The Curse

@ecojuche the kulaks were killed because they burned grain and killed livestock, but they were not the 6 bajillion that died in the famine

@Stern all of them?

@Aki the grain exports decreased because they had to keep more to feed people

@Bearer Of The Curse how would i aquire roles

what would cause a farmer to completely eradicate his livelihood?

@Stern where's the evidence?

sure activates my almonds

I'm sure they did it for absolutely no reason

Jesus you guys are still in this discussion, what is it now?

TL;DR "killing food production class doesnt cause mass starvation it was actually the fault of nasty western capitalist hucksters"

Nahhh... nahhh that is autistic. The grain exports decreased because there wasn't enough grain to go around.

yeah, let's not talk about how the Soviets forcefully took all grain from Farmers forcing them to Protest by burning stock @Xinyue didn't address this one time despite me asking on multiple occasions, i guess we all know why

@ecojuche they weren't the food production class, they were the landowner class

kulaks =/= catch all for peasant class

So when you argue that they decreased it as an act of good will you aren't really making a rational argumet there.

@Stern that's not how economics works you retard, you require a hierarchy, management is important

and yes, they were peasants

the management in collectives works differently

they weren't billionaires

So what now...

@Stern are you going to present an argument?

@Aki they decreased it to send grain to the actual non-aristocratic peasants

lol

>the management in collectives works differently

by not working?

@Stern the produce was all sent to big cities lol

That is a hella argument you are making there.

Wonder if you ever feel like making it in public on Ukraine.

what?

Lol