Message from Kombat-Unit in tradworker #tradworker
As to women at rallies I started a thread on therightstuff listeners group about why its a horrible idea. Ill give two quick reasons.
One, in the heat of a fight men will break rank and make tactically unwise decisions to rush every which way to help a woman who gets in danger. At cville 1.0 we faced just ONE enemy and this caused dozens of men to drop their hands and start getting the women away and turning away from the aggressive combatant. On a mass scale with a hell of a lot more chaos, thrown projectiles like bricks and piss and more enemies that is disastrous.
Two, women being physically weaker have to resort very quickly to escalating the situation by lethal means. Its either get beat badly, even to death or to stab or shoot the person. Either of those is a bad option. We don't want to shoot first. It makes us look weak as well it will make it hard to get an rally permits in the future. Just bad propaganda.
TWP leadership agrees we dont want our women there @MatthewHeimbach
I have a friend who has 88 on his knuckles
I agree on the Woman Question
by all means they should come to the non lee park events. Thats all well and good. But the rally is predicted to be violent by both sides.
There are the worst of antifa as well as many combative mma trained nogs who are libertardian types
Specifically trying to fighr
Even with 400 police we will have more people on both sides than we had at auburn and that shit went crazy even with full police lockdown
>One, in the heat of a fight men will break rank and make tactically unwise decisions to rush every which way to help a woman who gets in danger
Or, just have dedicated guards, problem solved.
Just brought this thing up a few days ago.
No problem not solved.
That's pointlessly taking away manpower for zero benefit, projectiles will still be thrown and in transit they can and will still be attacked
It'll be a fucking mess without dedicated guards even if it's just men, one antifa rushes a march, and 20s rush in to tear him apart.
No good reason for women to be there
How is it pointlessly taking manpower away if the guards are right there marching alongside you?
It's just the same amount of people, some are just geared better and prepared to beat commies.
Because they are being devoted to guarding useless people who shouldn't be there
And the march can continue without stops even if reds attack.
Even without women ,there should be picked dedicated guards.
Just cut out the middlewoman and leave them elsewhere
Have guards. But no women
You don't need to have women to have well equipped people
Yeah I mean, if reds manage to attack the march, that means your guards are useless. I mean, even at the risk of sounding egalitarian women have never been a problem no matter how many reds, because guards keep the reds away, no problem. You could have kids, for all I care.
@Kombat-Unit Shouldnt all young male members strive to be combat ready though?
And we did have a few times.
Well, yes, but it's suboptimal.
Like, once we had like 200 people, one red tries to attack one guy in the side, 20 guys rush to tear him apart, optimal situation, a few dedicated guards take him and march isnt even disrupted.
We have even told cops not to come.
But they still do.
There is no good reason to have them. Nothing good benefits
You just complained about guards taking away from the amount of marchers.
No I am saying men dont fight as well when they have the dual task of protecting a noncombatant and fighting at the same time. Most of the rally will be stationary anyway
Do you even have any idea of how this even is supposed to come down or are you just basing it off your local ones?
Rarely does anything ever go perfect so there is no reason to add more variables of women.
We love our women and want to protect them. That's natural and healthy.
When you have people who know their role, everyone can just take it easy, knowing their job. When its free for all, there's a risk of people wondering, "should I join that dogpile or not, who's gonna attack that dude, X". But when marches march and guards guard, its simple.
The best way to protect them is to not put them in danger in the first place