Cuz you described something having all traits

Which does not make sense

how does it not make sense?

As traits can be contradictory

As I already said

contradictions within laws he exists outside of though, that's the problem here

you're arguing within boundaries that he exists outside of

Then he ain’t perfect cuz perfection is a concept purely applicable to our world

contradictions have no potential lmao

i'm not understanding how you reach that conclusion though

if it is purely applicable to our world, and he exists outside of that world

how is it applicable to him therefore?

Why would god implant us with a concept we can’t actually comprehend

?

there is not such a thing as a potential square circle

Perfection would imply that tho

no

how are you coming up with that lol

I’m just going by Коровскы definition

for arguments sake, if he chose for it to exist then it very well could

but the reason why it doesnt is because he has not ordained the law to behave in such a way

again, we're trying to make arguments within boundaries he is not beholden to

So why did he invent the concept of it?

if he wanted a square circle to exist, he very well could have chosen to do so

that's a bit of a silly question, don't you think?

it's like asking why he invented mathematics

Because it helps us

Creating concepts we can’t comprehend doesn’t

lmao wtf is this argument

not really

I’m not understanding his definition of perfect @Spergerger

it would be just like saying 'god lets me ask if 1 + 1 can equal 5 so therefore he can't be perfect'

Your definition of perfect implies that tho

although its interesting to see addie has fled the discussion on aquinas after claiming to understand it

But yea this is getting pedantic

Let’s move on to something else

are you atheist @Gromp

Agnostic

fair enough
i used to be

yea