Message from @Gumbo - AZ

Discord ID: 510951489783726091


2018-11-10 22:51:39 UTC  

@Vilhjalmyr Interesting breakdown, thanks for sharing!

2018-11-10 22:51:50 UTC  

North Korea best Korea.

2018-11-10 22:52:22 UTC  

@TMatthews We don't get to be the ones that change the meaning of words. Maybe when we have control over the media, but we just can't do that right now. Even in America, if you talk to any educated person about economics, corporatism refers to a system where employers and employees are sorted into interest groups based on sector and the state mediates negotiations between them to make sure each side is fairly represented.

I'm not trying to be condescending, I'm just saying what the facts are. The fact is, if we just change the meaning of words whenever we want to, it's going to sounds silly to educated people. I'm sorry if saying that comes off the wrong way, but that's just the truth, and it has to be said.

2018-11-10 22:52:32 UTC  

Historically, the great era of capitalism saw the development of monopolies or oligopolies in every major industry. Oil (Rockefeller), Steel (Carnegie), Railroads (Vanderbilt), Explosives (DuPont), Sugar (Domino) etc

2018-11-10 22:53:12 UTC  

i don't think you have bad reasoning @TMatthews , but i agree with earlier comment about definitions. you're using common tongue rather than economics facts

2018-11-10 22:53:37 UTC  

Yeah but what do you guys think about Bitcoin?

2018-11-10 22:53:52 UTC  

It's not even common tongue. The word "corporatism" is rarely used outside of economics discussions.

2018-11-10 22:54:08 UTC  

@Jacob Again, I have literally never had a single person argue my definition and I've discussed this in college economics courses. If it matters so much, fine, pick a different word, but corporatism is a logical choice when critiquing excessive corporate power

2018-11-10 22:54:14 UTC  

@Nerv - VA Juche gang here, who up?>

2018-11-10 22:54:24 UTC  

@ThisIsChris it's decent only because we can't undo globalism, and it's a global commodity. worth holding some, but i'd hold physical gold first

2018-11-10 22:55:00 UTC  

OK how about Monero?

2018-11-10 22:55:16 UTC  

@TMatthews Because most people don't have the energy to argue it. How often do you argue with someone when they say something that sounds silly to you?

2018-11-10 22:55:31 UTC  

i think you might be able to make some money if you understand fundamentals and trading technicals with other coins, but bitcoin seems the most robust @ThisIsChris

2018-11-10 22:56:04 UTC  

BTC / LTC is the gold & silver - with ETH being more like oil with higher volatility and utility as "gas" for Dapps

2018-11-10 22:57:37 UTC  

@Jacob I'm literally an econ major. I would respectfully disagree and bring up the definition if someone used a definition I didn't agree with. Ultimately, however, the "people only pretended to agree because they think you're too stupid to argue with" argument has no basis in reality

2018-11-10 22:58:21 UTC  

if corporatism can only exist with a state apparatus, then it's not even related to capitalism

2018-11-10 22:58:34 UTC  

Exactly, it isn't

2018-11-10 22:58:43 UTC  

@Jacob As I have said repeatedly, you can use a different term. In fact, if you have one, by all means let me know. For communicating with ordinary people though, corporatism works well in my experience.

2018-11-10 22:58:44 UTC  

Corporatism is closer to socialism

2018-11-10 22:58:48 UTC  

^

2018-11-10 22:59:01 UTC  

Can you have a socialist blockchain?

2018-11-10 22:59:02 UTC  

Capitalism cannot exist without the state either

2018-11-10 22:59:27 UTC  

that's not true at all lol

2018-11-10 22:59:32 UTC  

Ancap would inevitably evolve into warlords

2018-11-10 23:00:00 UTC  

capitalism is simply relational values, it has no implied rule structure at all

2018-11-10 23:00:01 UTC  

Capitalism requires a stable currency, backed by government. We can't go back to bartering in the modern economy

2018-11-10 23:00:06 UTC  

that's false

2018-11-10 23:00:16 UTC  

hm

2018-11-10 23:00:30 UTC  

I'm running a sentiment analysis on this chat right now

2018-11-10 23:00:32 UTC  

stable currency is a creation OF capitalism to increase fungibility and liquidity

2018-11-10 23:00:39 UTC  

seems the issue is becoming contentious

2018-11-10 23:00:45 UTC  

Capitalism above all requires private property. For it to work, you need the state to enforce property rights

2018-11-10 23:00:53 UTC  

maybe we can change topic

2018-11-10 23:00:55 UTC  

I wish I was able to make it to DR

2018-11-10 23:00:56 UTC  

👮🏻

2018-11-10 23:01:29 UTC  

How bout that sportsball game?

2018-11-10 23:01:49 UTC  

@TMatthews Well, ultimately I can't prove whether it does or doesn't work in your experience because I wasn't there. Obviously if you think it's working if you, then there's nothing I can do to stop you. I'll just say that there are very many people who know what that words means, and it's going to sounds stupid to them to just make up definitions.

That's all, it's probably not productive to discuss further than this.

2018-11-10 23:01:57 UTC  

yeah, what sports are going on now, just foot ball right?

2018-11-10 23:02:30 UTC  

oh yeah hockey too

2018-11-10 23:02:54 UTC  

some local IE people we're thinking of attending an Islanders game