Message from @fuck12moredeadcops
Discord ID: 630826978890743818
Where was there a peaceful transition from feudalism to capitalism?
I’m just saying that it wasn’t the bourgeoise vs. the nobles
Like look at Lafayette
It literally was.
He was 2nd estate
Class traitors exist
And was a revolutionary
and people can engage in class suicide
Lol ok
Engels owned a factory
It is not unheard of for someone to go against their own class interest
Sure if you frame it like that, but that’s no-true-Scotsman logic
how..?
Small business - come in all shape and sizes
You’re framing any of the MANY liberal nobles, or conservative bourgeoise as class traitors
To force them into a narrative
The French Revolution was not even broadly about the 3rd estate vs the second estate
Like where do the enlightened monarchists fit in?
It is not forcing them into my narrative. If you were part of the noble classes, and you supported the expansion of land-ownership to the merchant class, you were working against the interest of the noble classes. You were absolutely a class traitor
No
and if you were a possessed merchant trying to maintain feudalism, despite the fact it prevented your ownership of private property, you'd be working against your own class interest
No, you wouldn’t
Being in one class and thinking like another does not make you a class traitor
Because you’d be trying to buy your way into the second estate
Meanwhile, a class of liberals (of all estates) we’re trying to give the king more power
While the conservatives wanted to devolve powers to the nobles
No, but actively fighting for the changing of the status quo, or maintenance of the status quo, in a way which harms your socioeconomic class, is the definition of being a class traitor @3v6en8
Shit then fuck me
I have an opinon on capital gains tax
fuck the poor
thats what i should do right?
So which were class traitors, the nobles who wanted to give more power to the king, or give more power to the regional assemblies
Like if you're a slave, and you fight for the maintenance of slavery, you're a class traitor against the enslaved classes
Here’s a different question- who in the French Revolution was NOT a class traitor
In the same way if you're a noble fighting for an end to feudal and semi-feudal conceptions of property and government, you are harming the class you're a part of
What if they were doing that because they felt it was their best chance to maintain power?
@Platinum Spark Nobles supporting the maintenance of the aristocracy, and business owners, merchants, and non-noble land owners trying to destroy the aristocracy and replace it with some type of democratic process
It’s just the whole French Revolution was WAY more complex than you’re making it out to be
Sure
Really complex
You can become a class traitor with the expectation that you'll be rewarded