Message from @Blackhawk342

Discord ID: 453721075402932236


2018-06-06 00:42:06 UTC  

You're looking for something that isn't there. It was just a badly written movie.

2018-06-06 00:42:19 UTC  

You're presuming that the empire wants her to survive

2018-06-06 00:42:31 UTC  

The loose ends aren't secret plot twists. They're just bad writing.

2018-06-06 00:42:50 UTC  

And what about her sister?

2018-06-06 00:42:59 UTC  

What sister?

2018-06-06 00:43:04 UTC  

Her sister died attacking First Order ships.

2018-06-06 00:43:15 UTC  

oh right at the start

2018-06-06 00:43:31 UTC  

Siblings dont have to support the same cause

2018-06-06 00:43:33 UTC  
2018-06-06 00:43:39 UTC  

dude stop

2018-06-06 00:43:45 UTC  

Just. Bad. Writing.

2018-06-06 00:43:47 UTC  

I cant remember, was that a story she was telling?

2018-06-06 00:44:08 UTC  

No, they spent several minutes focusing on the sister.

2018-06-06 00:44:09 UTC  

She mentioned if off hand at one point

2018-06-06 00:44:17 UTC  

cause what if it actually turned out.. that ter sister was on the death star or something

2018-06-06 00:44:22 UTC  

"killed by terrorists"

2018-06-06 00:44:30 UTC  

no they very clearly showed her dying

2018-06-06 00:44:41 UTC  

she was on the last bomber

2018-06-06 00:45:06 UTC  

but was that a scene... or was she telling the story and then it went into the scene?

2018-06-06 00:45:17 UTC  

no that was a scene

2018-06-06 00:45:34 UTC  

at this point you hadnt even met miss plumber comissar

2018-06-06 00:45:58 UTC  

ah yeah I remember... and then something about a necklace

2018-06-06 00:46:07 UTC  

thats it

2018-06-06 00:46:22 UTC  

unless... her sister was a spy too! 😛

2018-06-06 00:46:33 UTC  

cos their parents were on the death star

2018-06-06 00:46:33 UTC  

Literally the only plot hole that this fills in is the part where she crashes finn out of the way of the massive cannon

2018-06-06 00:47:27 UTC  

maybe kylo ren is her brother

2018-06-06 00:47:29 UTC  

That's not a plot hole. That was a conscious decision on the part of the writers.

2018-06-06 00:48:05 UTC  

Every male lead is stupid. Everything they do is pointless or downright wrong, and the female leads are meant to show them the error of their ways.

2018-06-06 00:48:37 UTC  

Finn, by trying to do something heroic and self-sacrificing, was wrong. The writers wanted that to be the lesson.

2018-06-06 00:48:54 UTC  

Yea im gonna consider that a plot hole

2018-06-06 00:49:13 UTC  

I refuse to believe that any studio could conciously decide that was a good idea for a movie

2018-06-06 00:49:31 UTC  

not sure if thats true... the feminist haired woman seemed fairly stubborn etc... but came through in the end

2018-06-06 00:50:04 UTC  

By a) not telling her subordinates what she was trying to do and b) breaking the SW universe.

2018-06-06 00:50:33 UTC  

Why didn't the rebels just evacuate a medical frigate and get a droid to crash it into the death star?

2018-06-06 00:51:24 UTC  

She assumed command and saw the discontent brewing amongst her crew

2018-06-06 00:51:54 UTC  

Instead of taking action to forestall it she chose to sit by and do nothing

2018-06-06 00:52:23 UTC  

Then at the end she made the wonderful decision to sacrifice herself, leaving the alliance without a fleet and without any leaders

2018-06-06 00:53:00 UTC  

But the important thing is that Poe was wrong about everything.

2018-06-06 00:53:20 UTC  

All that heroic stuff that we expect from dashing pilot male leads? Completely wrong.

2018-06-06 00:53:26 UTC  

"you cant solve your problems by jumping in an X wing and blowing everything up"