Message from @ReadWhom

Discord ID: 475669645475577856


2018-08-05 14:04:12 UTC  

Now that is fascinating

2018-08-05 14:04:23 UTC  

Its a summary, but a badly compiled one in your opinion?

2018-08-05 14:04:39 UTC  

Well people dont have the time.

2018-08-05 14:12:04 UTC  

Extremely badly in a sense

2018-08-05 14:13:00 UTC  

If it was to at least explain what it means with a lot of shit, it needs at least 3 a4 pages on each thing

2018-08-05 14:13:28 UTC  

Otherwise you could draw a very weird conclusion compared to the literature

2018-08-05 14:15:52 UTC  

For example: We (communists) want to abolish the family. Now, we do not want to abolish it to remover families altogether, what we want to abolish is the family you (the bourgeois) know of.

People take that out of it's context considering it's time and try to apply it in today, in which case they get the impression that here should be no homeschooling and society is the parents

2018-08-05 14:17:01 UTC  

Read other literature where they, Marx and Engels, talk about the family and what they want to change, they explain some fundamental differences between the working classes families and the bourgeois families

2018-08-05 14:17:06 UTC  

Thats the issue if it takes thousands of pages.

2018-08-05 14:17:13 UTC  

TO come to one conclusion

2018-08-05 14:17:25 UTC  

And then crush it down to double digits

2018-08-05 14:17:48 UTC  

and in short, most the points are that the labourers kids should have equall opportunity as the bourgeois kids

2018-08-05 14:17:58 UTC  

Yes

2018-08-05 14:18:14 UTC  

And considering that time period, the summary I gave wouldn't work

2018-08-05 14:19:12 UTC  

Then how did it become what it is now?

2018-08-05 14:19:22 UTC  

People forget that a different time period must be considered not only as to why something was worded the way it was, but also why it wasn't worded in a, in our time, better way

2018-08-05 14:19:29 UTC  

How the hell did it turn from empowering the worker to subjugating the population

2018-08-05 14:19:37 UTC  

As you said, ppl are lazy and just read the manifesto

2018-08-05 14:20:12 UTC  

And then someone on top realises if he cherry picks pages from Das Kapital he can get ppl on his side to help him get more power

2018-08-05 14:21:08 UTC  

Jesus its like the koran

2018-08-05 14:21:20 UTC  

I've met communists that are like "I have only read some parts of Das Kapital" and coincidentally it os the parts in which the state is the hero and the companies are evil. Never a single part that praises parts of capitalism

2018-08-05 14:21:51 UTC  

Or that distinguishes percieved capitalism from actual capitalism

2018-08-05 14:22:48 UTC  

He does explain how the free market, on the contrary to how it is percieved, is separate from capitalism

2018-08-05 14:23:15 UTC  

Have you heard of a commie that is part of a big commie group ever say anything like that?

2018-08-05 14:23:41 UTC  

They are always against the free market because it is capitalistic (in a russian accent)

2018-08-05 14:24:18 UTC  

Ive never met a commie like that. You know, one that knows that much. But then again, Im not gonna pretend I read Marx's work

2018-08-05 14:25:49 UTC  

You consider me a commie?

2018-08-05 14:28:03 UTC  

I didnt say that

2018-08-05 14:28:23 UTC  

Like I said I never met a commie that knows that much.

2018-08-05 14:28:51 UTC  

Much like I never met a christian who knows the bible beyond memorizing verses

2018-08-05 14:31:08 UTC  

Oh, ok

2018-08-05 14:31:11 UTC  

Just checking

2018-08-05 14:34:11 UTC  

The people I find more knowledgable on relligion ive met are people who dont practice it as much

2018-08-05 14:34:21 UTC  

I would probably consider myself a Marxist if it wasn't for those that already do. Don't wanna be associated with those shets

2018-08-05 14:34:22 UTC  

As they are more likely to question it

2018-08-05 14:34:41 UTC  

And Id considermyself ancap if it wernt for those who already do

2018-08-05 14:38:16 UTC  

I'd say I am a decentralist

2018-08-05 15:41:00 UTC  

To be honest, govt seizing the means of production does not scream decentralization

2018-08-05 15:45:53 UTC  

I know

2018-08-05 15:46:43 UTC  

The reason real communisms haven't existed is because there has always been a state. They want to rid of the state

2018-08-05 16:05:35 UTC  

But so called communists want to first make the state own EVERYTHING, and then rid of the state. Good luck making someone with all that power give it up