but we're not talking about the water in your body

that would be stealing.... if i purified shit water .... bottled it, and you stole it... ya that would be stealing..... ? lol

Poptarts brought it up

to avoid getting too theoretical, here's a good concrete example:
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/nestl%C3%A9-faces-renewed-criticism-as-b-c-drought-continues-1.3145929

somebody else started asking about "privatizing" water .... AS IF ppl dont own their own bottles of water!! LOL

Yeah, but what you own is the bottle, not the water

as if ppl dont *already* own ... etc

You drink the water, you piss it out

Nestle bottling groundwater that it does not pay for and then selling it

lol says who?

thats not true at all

of course you own the water within the bottle

So you're saying that your body has retained *every single drop* of water you've ever consumed

the question is not "is it possible to own water"

no, i have never said that at all

Then how can you own water?

it is impossible to own water

looks... .the water in your fridge or my giant water bottles is PRIVATE

facts

nobody can lawfully take that from me ... its private property already

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/12/27/573774328/california-says-nestle-lacks-permits-to-extract-millions-of-gallons-of-water

Ok so this isnt water but i talked to a guy who has placed solar panels on his home and his home has effectively become a power station, in exchange for providing power to his neighborhood he gets tax cuts and the major power company has to pay HIM for his provision of power or something like that, he didnt give me details.

i told you guys, Ownership is an agreement,

If someone disagrees, then you have to either claim it through sovereign right, or release ownership

the state is meant to protect your right to private property (police)

ive heard about that, Lago

so let's say you pour your water into a bowl and it evaporates. who do you sue?

its impossible to own a bowl

no, you dont need somebody else permission to create your own property/value with your own labor

I said "a bowl," I didn't imply you owned the bowl

it doesnt depend on the agreement of others for you to exercise absolute property rights

property rights come from God?

see Poptarts the issue is there's no cosmic property registry that tracks ownership of everything

its impossible to own god

nobody, hearts... nobody stole it from me... it evaporated bcuz of poor management

so obviously jsut gets diluted back into the environment

You can create resources, you can't Own them unless you lay claim to it

I can take it from you, if i take it you don't own it anymore

its impossible to steal

for anybody to extract again and use

so it becomes ownerless then

you can't own what you create unless you enforce your claim on it

have you ever seen There Will Be Blood?