philosophy
Discord ID: 686291889653416085
2,957 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev |
Page 5/30
| Next
Do it on the daily basis, if you truly seek the truth, god will supply you with it
i used to pray every evening when i was younger i dont know it somehow got lost over time
i should start reading the bible
surely
i started reading the bible too when i was younger too but i dont think i got very far actually i wasnt the biggest reader back then
@Sentient23 The Romans passage is more "Respect authority" rather than prescribing monarchy per se
conetxtually they were speaking of the monarch
So if a monarch is tyrannical or corrupt, then should Christians not rebel against said monarch?
@Sentient23 it is not the government's job to enforce the bibles morals
except in the case of public decency because that is a bit different
Of course not. Again if you actually read the context, that concern is answered
Why cherry pick where you apply Christian morality and where you not apply Christian morality? Which criteria is being used for when its okay to apply and when it isn't? And why?
I'm not Christian
and I think religion should mostly stay out of legislation
because if you do this then you isolate other religions
You said that there would be circumstances in which Christian morality would be enforced?
when did I say that
"except in the case of public decency"
that has nothing to do with Christian morals
I just think that children shouldn't see grown men naked
Then why say "except in such and such cases" when you previously said "the government shouldnt enforce bibles morals"
because that is an exception
and because it harms other citizens
Why is that an exception?
because it can mentally scar children
So?
I don't want children to be mentally scarred
That's all
I am have lax views on what is allowed and what isn't but atleast do it with some pants on for the love of god
You can't justify it without religion, which is the point
yes you can
you can say how it harmfully affects children
that has nothing to do with religion
yes but you cant explain why that in and of itself is bad fundamentally speaking
because mental health is important
why should i suppress my pleasurie urges just because some kid willl be scared? At the end of the day, its just two pieces of meat rubbing against one another, in which one piece of meat has a chemical react in a certain way, and the other also has a chemical react in a certain way?
because mental health is fuckin important
at that point you are exposing the child to something harmful
thus infringing upon its rights
Its rights?
Are you seriously defending people who walk naked around children? @Sentient23
Lol justify that its a right to not have your mental health downplayed
@Florida Man Im demonstrating the absurdity of atheism
calm down bucko
you are right, I misspoke, I meant that it is harming the child
you don't need religion to justify that that is bad
Again, So what. Why should "mental health is important" trump my mental health which would gets an urge to sexually abuse children every 2 weeks
Yes you do
Without religion, morality is subjective
Fundamentally speaking, you can't justify it
Without appealing to a higher being
no there should be a standard in place, if it harms another being, then it is immoral
Why
and also if you are harmed by not harming other people, then a mental institution should be recommended
Wait why? I'm not harming anyone am I? And yet I'm being harmed, so its immoral for me not to molest children, but its also immoral if i molest children
you are harming the child
if you are harmed by not harming then that is immoral
Exactly
based on the same standard I already stated
See the contradiction?
no I am not
Me not molesting children is immoral
But me molesting children is immoral
So wait, if I harm another man, it's immoral, but if I don't harm another man, it's also immoral?
The latter being true entails the falsity of the former, but the former is true, but if the former is true, it entails the falsity of the latter. Which breaks the law of non contradiction
yes I misspoke
what I meant to say is that you cannot use that justification if that involves harming another being
and that an alternate solution should be prescribed then
No well those are the only two alternatives
If i get put into a mental institution i obviously don't get to rape children
If I don't get put in a mental institution, but refrain from raping children, i still get hurt
but if i decide to rape children, it would also be immoral
no but you get help to diminish that urge
no it is not immoral to be in a mental institution
You realize that's impossible
Its impossible to cure pedophiles
Which is why people wanna just kill them
No?
google it
That's demonstrably false
Those who are given therapy are statistically less likely to reoffense
me going to a mental institution would entail me not raping kids, but me not raping kids would harm me mentally
@โงโฝ ๐น ๐ ๐ ๐ถ ๐ ๐พ ๐ ๐ โพโง Incorrect. You need to prove that its the therapy that does it not the fear of jail
There's legitimate statistics on the reoffense rate of those who are given therapy and those who aren't and those who do receive it reoffense less
Incorrect. You need to prove that its the therapy that does it not the fear of jail
Well it's consistent with rehabilitation oriented crime stats across the world
Ok?
Which are proven to be more effective in lowering offense rates than prison systems
How does that demonstrate its the therapy rather than fear of jail
Well you are aware that the ones who go to jail reoffend more than those who get treatment?
that you don't need religion to justify that public indecency is bad
That literally ends the argument right there
Provide evidence that those who go to jail reoffend more than those who go to therapy in terms of pedophilia
@moira Yes you do mate. Even mainstream atheists agree
with this
You mean in terms of sexual violence?
Yes
Pedophilia and sexual offense aren't synonymous
You don't
Well we were referring about "making an offense'
am I a mainstream atheist?
2,957 total messages. Viewing 100 per page.
Prev |
Page 5/30
| Next